StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Relationship of Hard TQM, Soft TQM with Organizational Performance - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper “Relationship of Hard TQM, Soft TQM with Organizational Performance” seeks to evaluate Hard TQM, which was responsible for a greater percentage in evaluating organizational performance. However, Soft TQM indirectly affects an organization’s performance through its effect on hard TQM elements…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95% of users find it useful
Relationship of Hard TQM, Soft TQM with Organizational Performance
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Relationship of Hard TQM, Soft TQM with Organizational Performance"

Partha kar Academia-Research, Inc Total Quality Management 20 February 2007 Relationship of Hard TQM, Soft TQM with Organisational Performance: Summary: It was profoundly believed that Hard TQM was responsible to a greater percentage in evaluating organisational performance and I do not say that holds false. However Soft TQM indirectly affects an organisation's performance through its effect on hard TQM elements. Analysis of 261 Australian manufacturing companies revealed significant positive relationships between soft TQM and hard TQM elements. In addition to direct affects, soft TQM also has an indirect affect on performance through its effect on hard TQM. Introduction: Empirical studies which have examined the relationship between the Total Quality Management (TQM) and organisational performance have investigated the impact of each dimension of TQM on performance separately (Powell, 1995; Dow et al., 1999; Samson and Terziovski, 1999; Rahman, 2001). TQM is viewed in two ways. The first approach conceptualizes TQM as a limited set of technical tools(such as statistical process control and Pareto analysis) while the second approach views TQM as part of broader changes to human resource (HR) practices. Soft TQM corresponds to human factors like commitment, team work and so on which contributes to organisational performance. It plays dual roles. One is to create an environment where seamless diffusion and implementation of hard TQM can take place, and the other is to directly affect organisation's performance in the same way that traditional human resource management (HRM) practices impact organizations. (Ahire et al. 1996). Hard TQM tools tend to be more profound in companies that adopt strategies to increase stakeholder commitment and incorporate the views of employees in decision making processes. It views the organization on the whole as a system. It can be concluded that soft TQM will affect elements of hard TQM, in addition to having a direct impact on performance. In this study Organisational performance is expressed using seven variables used by (Samson and Terziovski, 1999) amongst six variables of soft TQM used by (Dow et al. 1999) and the four elements of hard TQM adopted by (Power et al, 2001). TQM influences organisation's performance in the following ways: 1. Direct effect of soft TQM on organisation's performance: Three (executive commitment, open organization and employee empowerment) of 12 soft TQM factors correlate to corporate performance (Powel, 1995). Again 3 (workforce commitment, shared vision and customer locus) of 9 factors influence corporate performance (Dow et, 1999). 2. Indirect effect of soft TQM on organisation's performance: Here soft TQM influences hard TQM for performance. A blend is required as attention to process, product and information technology may yield quality improvements, but ultimately it is 'people that make quality happen' (Bowen, 1992). Executives appear to understand that employee motivation, education and corporate culture all have an important role to play in efforts to improve quality, even if they are uncertain about how HR-based quality improvements can be implemented in practice (Bowen & Hart). 3. Direct effect of Hard TQM on corporate performance: Hard TQM contemplates in stressing continuous improvement and treat organization as total systems (Sitkin et al, 1994). For instance, product and process benchmarking has resulted in optimal product design and process cost reduction at companies such as Ford, Motorola, Xerox and General Motors (Main and Templin, 1992). Brief Description of areas investigated: A total of 3000 Australian manufacturing sites were surveyed of which 962 sites responded, yielding a response rate of 32 percent. A telephone survey of 108 non-respondents was conducted after the main survey, and no evidence of non-response bias was found (AMC, 1994). Since the survey instrument consisted of a large number of questions (a total of 260), the results of the survey were also tested for respondent fatigue. It was found that the length and complexity of the survey instrument did not seriously affect the quality of the responses (AMC, 1994). The various areas investigated were: Operational Dimensions of Soft TQM: Soft TQM dimensions were adopted from study by Dow (Dow et al,1999). A total of 25 items were identified as soft TQM practices. These items were grouped into six elements & coefficient alpha were calculated for each element. The reliability coefficient (Cronbach's alpha) of the elements ranged between 0.70 (Co-operative supplier relations) and 0.84 (Workforce Commitment). The alpha values indicate that each dimension is a sufficiently reliable measure(Nunnally, 1967). Operational Dimensions of Hard TQM: The items used by Dow (Dow et al, 1999) to identify hard TQM practices were considered to be too narrow. Hard TQM items were therefore adopted from study by Power (Power et al, 2001). A total of 13 items were identified as indicators of hard TQM practices. These items were grouped into four elements and coefficient alpha was calculated for each. The reliability alpha values of the elements ranged between 0.55 (Technology utilization) and 0.86 (Computer-based technologies). The alpha value of 0.55 for the technology utilization scale is considered low, but it was left intact on the basis of its construct and face validity. Operational Measures of Organisational Performance: The items related to organisational performance were adopted from (Samson and Terziovski, 1999). This construct has seven items and was considered to be more comprehensive than the four items used in the study by (Dow et al, 1999). These items are shown in Table 1 (See figure 1). Simple regression and hierarchical regression analysis was used in the analysis. Key learning points: The above analyses have shown the following: Soft TQM have got direct effects on organisational performance. Both Technology utilization and Continuous improvement enablers are significantly related to five out of six Soft TQM elements and Use of JIT principles is related to four out of six soft TQM elements. Computer-based Figure 1: Items related to organisational Performance technologies have a significant correlation only with Personnel training. Thus proving that soft TQM indirectly influences hard TQM. Both Dew and Powell have found the dimensions of hard TQM to be weakly related or unrelated to performance. Critical analysis and discussion: The results of this study suggest that in general, the elements of soft TQM are significantly related to the measures of organisational performance. Five out of six soft TQM elements have a positive liaison with organisational performance. These are Workforce commitment, Shared vision, Customer focus, Use of teams, and Cooperative supplier relations. Most importantly what does matter when selecting between soft and hard TQM is the nature of the organization and its available resources to be managed. Three out of four elements of hard TQM--Use of JIT principles, Technology utilization, and Continuous improvement enablers--have significant relationships with all six soft TQM elements. Practical implementations: In addition to the direct impact of soft TQM elements on performance, soft TQM indirectly affects performance through hard TQM elements. Soft TQM elements affect Continuous improvement enablers, which in turn affects three measures of performance such as Customer satisfaction, Productivity, and Delivery in full. This pattern of direct impact on Continuous improvement enablers and indirect impact on three measures of performance was observed for five of the six soft TQM elements. This pattern was observed for all performance measures with the exception of Customer focus. Workforce commitment, Shared vision, and Cooperative supplier relations affect three out of four hard TQM elements (Use of JIT principles, Technology utilization, and Continuous improvement enablers). Each one of these in turn affects the Productivity performance measure. Elements of soft TQM affect Use of JIT principles, which in turn affects Employee morale, Productivity, Warranty cost, and Cost of Quality. This was observed for four of the six elements of soft TQM, with the exception of Use of teams and Personnel training. Workforce commitment, Shared vision, Customer focus, and Cooperative supplier relations have a direct impact on Use of JIT principles and Technology utilization which in turn affects Cost of quality. Conclusion: In practice both the soft and hard TQM techniques are exercised based on the availability of resources of an organization and its focus towards the customers. A manufacturing company is more focused on supplier relations than a service organization. The type of organization to a large extent influences the type of TQM to be implemented or the priority of the TQM types to be attached importance. Recommendations: The main findings of this research are relevant to both quality management researchers and practicing managers. For researchers the paper presents an alternative methodology to assess not only the direct impacts of soft and hard TQM on performance, but the indirect impact of soft TQM on performance via hard TQM elements. This corresponds to calls made by Powell for the use of alternative methodologies in research on quality management. For practicing managers, this study, like those of Dew et al., Powell and Samson and Terziovski, suggests that soft TQM elements affect organisational performance. In addition, this study provides evidence that certain hard TQM elements have a significant effect on performance and suggests that for hard TQM to impact performance, it is essential that such hard elements are supported by the elements of soft TQM. References Ahire, L. .S., Golhar, D. Y. and Waller, M. A.,1996, Development and validation of TQM implementation constructs, Decision Sciences, 27,1, 23-56. AMC (Australian Manufacturing Council), 1994, Leading the Way: A study of best Manufacturing Practices in Australia and New Zealand, Melbourne. Bowen, D. and Lawler, L.,1992, Total quality-oriented human resource management, Organisational Dynamics, 24, 4, 39-41. Dow, D., Samson, D. and Ford, S.,1999, Exploding the myth: do all quality management practices contribute to superior quality performance, Production and Operations Management, 8,1, 1-27. Ergas H, Wright M. Internationalisation, firm conduct and productivity. In: Lowe P, Dwyer J, editors. Proceedings of the 1994 Conference on International Integration of the Australian Economy, Reserve Bank of Australia, Sydney. Hart, M. and Schlesinger, J.,1991, "Total quality management and human resource professional", Human Resource Management, 30, 4, 433-454. Nunnaally, J. C., 1967, Psychometric Theory, McGraw-Hill, NY. Power, D. J., Amrik, S. S. and Rahman, S.,2001, Critical success factors in agile supply chain management, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, 31,4, 247-265. Powell, T. C.,1995, Total quality management as competitive advantage: a review and empirical study, Strategic Management Journal, 16,1, 15-37. Rahman, S. 2001, A comparative study of TQM practice and organisational performance of SMEs with and without ISO 9000 certification, International Journal of Quality and Reliability Management, 18,1, 35-49. Samson, D., and Terzioski, M.,1999, The relationship between total quality management and operational performance, Journal of Operations Management, 17, 393-409. Sitkin, S. B., Sutcliffe, K. M., and Schroeder, R. G.,1994, Distinguishing control from learning in total quality management: a contingency perspective, Academy of Management Journal, 19,3, 537-564. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Relationship of Hard TQM, Soft TQM with Organizational Performance Assignment, n.d.)
Relationship of Hard TQM, Soft TQM with Organizational Performance Assignment. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/business/1512797-total-quality-management-article
(Relationship of Hard TQM, Soft TQM With Organizational Performance Assignment)
Relationship of Hard TQM, Soft TQM With Organizational Performance Assignment. https://studentshare.org/business/1512797-total-quality-management-article.
“Relationship of Hard TQM, Soft TQM With Organizational Performance Assignment”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/business/1512797-total-quality-management-article.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Relationship of Hard TQM, Soft TQM with Organizational Performance

Total Quality Leadership

Understand the Total Quality Leadership and how this type of leadership can improve organizational performance I.... As a management approach, TQL capitalizes on the theory of variation, the application of systems, the mind set of the person or team of persons and the scientific means of pursuing optimum performance (Houston and Dockstader, 1997).... As a scientific approach to management, TQL facilitates good performance and the proper delivery of services to maximize productivity (Suarez, 1992)....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Concept of Quality and Total Quality

With this concern, the report intends to discuss the concept of quality along with total quality and identification of hard as well as soft problems faced by RWDi.... Total Quality Management The idea of Total Quality Management (tqm) can be defined as the level of optimisation and amalgamation of all business activities and processes that facilitate the organisations to comply with the anticipation of their customers (University of Liverpool, n.... An effective practice of tqm is considerably focused on promoting customer's needs and demands at large....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Hard factors of TQM implementation in the Project division at GASCO

Research questions With reference to the hard factors of TQM, this research will try to establish how effectively GASCO utilizes these factors to achieve organizational performance.... Objectives of the report TQM, being an important element in achieving organizational performance, contributes to the achievement of organizational goals and objectives (Salaheldin 2009, p.... The main objective of this report is establishing the extent to which TQM contributes to organizational performance, with reference to GASCO....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Does Total Quality Management Improve Manufacturing Production Systems

In the process, the relationship of practice and performance is investigated and the practices and performance of firms with or without TQM and ISO 9000 in the manufacturing industry are examined.... nbsp; Empirical results of this study are expected to show that there would be a marginal increase in performance over a 4-year and 6-year period, respectively, upon installing ISO and TQM programmes.... This study was conducted to investigate the effects of ISO 9000 and TQM either singly or in combination on the performance of companies....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

The contribution of measurement and information infrastructure to TQM success

Taylor and Wright posit that it is not clear and that it is debatable whether Total Quality Management contributes to improve performance.... It was based on the gathered information from the companies on: Customer satisfaction; employee satisfaction; and, process performance.... They questioned the importance of TQM on the basis of measurement and customer focus absence and suggested the need for organizational awareness of performance through the practices of benchmarking and self-assessment....
7 Pages (1750 words) Article

INFORMING AND INVOLVING EMPLOYEES HRM

EI has been identified as a means to secure commitment and high performance which has resulted in an increase in the interest in employee involvement and participation.... performance is a function of ability, motivation and Oppurtunity.... Different definitions and interpretations have been given of the term EIP which ranges from encouraging commitment to achieve organizational success or exercising influence over their work or personal involvement of organization al workers....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Research Change Models, Diagnosis Instruments, and Specific Change Interventions

Changes to any of the elements of hard S would have a direct impact on all the soft Ss and also on the entire organization.... The best part is that this model can be applied at individual, team and organizational levels.... First developed by Kurt Lewin (1947), force field analysis can be used as a diagnostic instrument in assessing reactions to organizational change (Hughes, 2007).... In this model, Lewin identified three processes involved in any change mechanism, which include unfreezing, moving and refreezing of organizational processes (Anderson, 2009)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Weaknesses and the Best Measures of Corrections of Grayson Manufacturing

With the current changing market Grayson is finding it hard to keep abreast of the ever eluding market demand.... "Weaknesses and the Best Measures of Corrections of Grayson Manufacturing" paper outlines profoundly the best practices which will revive the company from its predicament....
15 Pages (3750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us