StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Private School Choice Throughout the United States - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Private School Choice Throughout the United States" focuses on the notion of an accountability mechanism for education institutions that includes incentives and sanctions. The notion of an accountability mechanism for education institutions is contentious and unconventional…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.3% of users find it useful
The Private School Choice Throughout the United States
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Private School Choice Throughout the United States"

Running Head: English Private School Choice: A Public-Private Education Controversy An Argumentative Paper Submission Introduction Private school choice was the core of the education program of the Bush administration, and it was the sole education agenda campaigned by the President during the presidential election of 1992. It has been the target of a growing number of referendum proposals, legislations, and education hearings (Hakim, Seidenstat, & Bowman, 1994). The argument of ‘private school choice’ states that students in private schools perform much better than students in public schools (Cookson, 1992). This paper argues against this prevailing assumption. Hence, this paper tries to answer two major questions: (1) is the argument of private school choice advocates well-founded; and (2) do private schools actually cater to the same students and achieve much better outcomes? The Public-Private Education Debate The private school choice is not the first education program to ask the public to finance the tuition fees of students who are selected by private schools (Cookson, 1992). This should be expected. Private schools do not have desegregation directives, teacher unions, red tape, affirmative action, or tenure to deal with; they are vulnerable only to the regulation of the market. Hence, so as to solve the problem in education and on behalf of equality, parents, particularly low-income parents, should be permitted to make use of public resources to enroll their children in private schools. According to Alrdrich (2004), what differentiates this program for public assistance to private education from other education agendas is that it is being promoted almost entirely on account of education reform and development; certainly, as the education program that would render any others futile. James S. Coleman, whose study in 1981 on the differences of public schools and private schools in terms of performance is regarded as the leading source of empirical substantiation of the superiority of private schools, cautioned that “one should not make a mistake: Our estimates for the size of the private-sector effects show them not to be large” (Cookson, 1992, 137). Few researchers have reported that the slight private school advantage discovered by Coleman vanished when differences in pupils’ course preference and family context were considered (Cookson, 1992). John Chubb and Terry Moe are the current sources of ‘impartial evidence’ of the superiority of private school. Numerous policymakers and opinion-editorial writers have reiterated their argument as dogma, and large numbers of people have been convinced of public assistance for private schools on their influence (Hakim et al., 1994). As analytical writers and peer analysts have emphasized, the study of Chubb and Moe of private and public high schools falls short in locating a private school lead when pupils’ course preferences and background attributes are examined. The failure of the investigation of Chubb and Moe to provide them substantiation for their arguments is not that unexpected. The proof they draw upon originates entirely from the ‘High School and Beyond Study’, the information that also botched Coleman’s study (Hakim et al., 1994, 66). Furthermore, in spite of the many pages they used on justifying why their treatment of this information is superior over the methodologies of other researchers, Chubb and Moe disregard almost all that has been taught about how to ethically deal with significantly erroneous, otherwise insignificant, information (Cookson, 1992). Yet, they chose to work unconventionally. Some of their questionable methods are (Hakim et al., 1994, 66): (1) developing a school organization instrument consisting of a large number of factors, making it practically unattainable to isolate the impacts of any one factor; (2) merging private and exclusive private schools alongside Catholic ones in a manner that involuntarily awarded a private school lead in their study; (3) and disclosing findings in terms of average disparities between schools in the lowest quartile to the highest quartile, which comprises disproportionate comparisons. As convincingly emphasized by John Witte, “They never directly test the differential effect of public and private schools on achievement… [P]rior studies either ran separate regressions for public and private school students, or analyzed all students together but included a variable indicating whether the student was in a public or private school. They did neither” (Hakim et al., 1994, 67). Valerie Lee and Anthony Bryk referred to the “popular acceptance of this book as a source of scientific evidence to support its policy recommendations… unfortunate” (Hakim et al., 1994, 67). The risks entailed by public assistance to private education are considerable, and they are not counteracted by any proof of educational gain. Indeed, the findings of national studies such as the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) reveal that if the American government aspires to gain top-notch education outcomes, then converting tax resources to entrust them to private schools will be useless. If private schools fail to do better than public schools, then groups or individuals who have argued that democratic regulation or teacher unions or red tape is mainly accountable for the problem in American education had to consider other factors because private schools are not held back by any of these forces. In contrast, it also implies that public schools cannot charge their poor outcomes largely on the weakening of communities and families. According to Alrdrich (2004), although they were to acquire the sorts of learners private schools admit, specially selected and with parents who are quite highly educated and encouraged to invest on education, and even though, similar to private schools, were to gain greater flexibility in getting rid of nuisances and smaller number of students in every classroom, performance of private schools in national examinations show that academic performance would remain at a point that is far lower global standards. The findings of comparative studies between public and private schools may be unexpected, but they are in fact not astounding. Private and public schools generally have similar curriculum, workbooks, monitoring procedures, internal structures, and similar unsympathetic values and norms. The dismal performance of both private and public schools suggest that there is not a lot to the assumption that the rivalry which school choice would generate would function as a remarkable accountability mechanism. The assumption is that parents would make educational choices based on first-rate academic performance; thus high-performing schools would thrive and be emulated and low-performing schools would not succeed. As argued by Hakim and colleagues (1994), there are parents who prefer private education in spite, as NAEP reveals, of their average performance, and this indicates that if school choice generates accountability, it is not constantly or largely based on educational performance and value. Conclusions School choice could be an exceptional encouragement for schools to strive more to draw the attention of customers but it is no replacement for planning educational motivations where in there are incentives for enhancing academic performance and sanctions for failure. The notion of an accountability mechanism for education institutions that includes incentives and sanctions is contentious and unconventional. The notion of an accountability mechanism founded on private school choice is contentious and unconventional too, and the NAEP and other findings reveal that it would fail. It is quite evident that even though the people refuse to accept private school choice, it will not cope with the existing situation in public education. There are two possibilities: one, there will be a novel form of accountability process in education that the educator and the people can trust, or, second, some unwise accountability program that will only harm education will be enforced. The private school choice programs that are being promoted throughout the United States will not assist students in realizing that they have to exert a lot of effort in school to achieve their goals. They will fail to motivate schools to concentrate on enhancing academic performance and to explore other strategies of doing so. They definitely will fail to eliminate the impacts of childhood poverty. They will fail to alleviate the predicament in education because that predicament troubles both private and public schools. References Aldrich, R. (2004). Public or Private Education? Lessons from History. London: Woburn Press. Cookson, P. (1992). The Choice controversy. The University of Michigan: Corwin Press. Hakim, S., Seidenstat, P. & Bowman, G. (1994). Privatizing Education and Educational Choice: Concepts, Plans, and Experiences. Westport, CT: Praeger. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Private School Choice Throughout the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words, n.d.)
The Private School Choice Throughout the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. https://studentshare.org/education/1757994-position-paper-outline-what-are-the-differences-between-public-and-private-education
(The Private School Choice Throughout the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
The Private School Choice Throughout the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/education/1757994-position-paper-outline-what-are-the-differences-between-public-and-private-education.
“The Private School Choice Throughout the United States Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”. https://studentshare.org/education/1757994-position-paper-outline-what-are-the-differences-between-public-and-private-education.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Private School Choice Throughout the United States

Michelle Obama should be one of 2010 most influnce people in TIME Magezine

hellip; Michelle Obama is one of the most influential people in America and would be an appropriate choice for TIME magazine's 100 most influential people because of her support on helping American obese kids and military families throughout the united states.... Obama is the wife of the 44th President of the united states, Barack Obama.... She is African- American First Lady of the united states.... Obama makes sure that the country recognizes the men and women who sacrifice themselves to protect the united states of America....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Jonas Salk

This success enabled Salk to attend City College of New York, which is one of the most competitive colleges in the united states.... Salk attended the local public schools of New York, but when it was time for him to begin high school at the young age of thirteen, he was sent to Townsend Harris High school.... This high school was a free alternative to the expensive private schools for intellectually gifted students, catering to intellectually talented males of immigrant parents, just like Salk (McPherson 11)....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

The US Should Not Have Fought in Vietnam

hellip; Why was the united states there to begin with Over the almost thirty years since America withdrew from Vietnam, countless people have espoused their views on why or why not America should have been involved to begin with.... In examining the united states' presence in Vietnam, I have come to the conclusion that the united states should not have fought in Vietnam.... the united states blocked that.... Why - Quite simply because the united states knew that Ho Chi Minh would have won the free election and a Socialist leader would have established in the country....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Stake holder Research Paper

It began with to bringing up the actuality of in todays united states; almost one in five of people in general schools obliged their learner to wear their school garbs while they are in school.... This research paper is going to investigate the part of stakeholder with respect to the dressing line of the school and the convention of the school uniform.... hellip; meeting feature being titled as "Are school garbs helping or blocking?...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Chinese Society and Culture

So I think feminist movement is very necessary and important throughout human history and it should be continued now and in the future.... I believe that in a relationship my girlfriend should listen to me when we have to make a choice or decide an important issue.... But now… They have their own work and they can have their private space....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Police and Crime Control

Structured in 1908 the Federal Bureau of Investigation started as an element that could research and authorize particular elected laws as an investigative and "law authorization organization" in the united states.... ather, group policing is a quality framework, which penetrates a police officer, in which the essential authoritative objective is working helpfully with unique nationals, aggregations of natives, and both open and private associations to distinguish and intention issues which possibly impact the bearableness of particular neighborhoods, regions, or the city all in all....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us