StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

When student is an occupation: Caught in an economic quagmire, the educated class turns to OWS - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The article entitled “When student is an occupation: Caught in an economic quagmire, the educated class turns to OWS” published on October 28, 2011 by Marissa Brotsoff argues that the students and recent graduates who are currently occupying Wall Street represent a much maligned group who are “among the victims of regressive economic policies and among the potential beneficiaries of social change” (Brotsoff, 2011, p. 1) …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
When student is an occupation: Caught in an economic quagmire, the educated class turns to OWS
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "When student is an occupation: Caught in an economic quagmire, the educated class turns to OWS"

?Rebuttal Essay. The article en d “When is an occupation: Caught in an economic quagmire, the educated turns to OWS” published on October 28, 2011 by Marissa Brotsoff argues that the students and recent graduates who are currently occupying Wall Street represent a much maligned group who are “among the victims of regressive economic policies and among the potential beneficiaries of social change” (Brotsoff, 2011, p. 1) The author maintains that this generation of students have been cornered into an “unattainable, unaffordable model of success” (Brotsoff, 2011, p.1) and have in effect been left high and dry by a society that promised them much, much more. This amounts to a serious grievance, in the author’s opinion but in fact this generation of graduates is the most privileged that the country has ever seen. While there is no doubt that the author speaks from a sense of injustice and resentment, there is considerable evidence that her argument is not based on a balanced reading of the facts. She maintains that that graduate unemployment is rising and salaries are falling, which is true of the last couple of years, but this must be seen in a broader perspective. A closer look at some of the statistics from recent years on the economic advantages that college education brings, shows clearly that it is worthwhile in financial terms to achieve a degree. The following graph based on data from 2002 comprising a group of over 25 year olds who were in full time employment expressed this in a format using constant 2002 dollars, to compensate for inflation: Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Oct 23, 2003. http://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2003/oct/wk3/art04.htm Over this period both women and men with less than a high school diploma have suffered a decline in their inflation adjusted earnings, but those who are fortunate enough to have completed college degrees have increased their income by one-third (women) or one fifth (men). These are huge gains which have accumulated over time. The gender differences are due to the slow progress that is being made towards the equalization of salary levels. What this graph shows very clearly is the trend towards increased wealth in those who go to college. Such people are indeed an elite in real terms, as far as income is concerned, and even if in present times there is a slowing or slight reversal of this trend, this does not wipe out the huge gains that were made in the 1980s and 1990s. The author is not correct in identifying a genuine grievance, since the slight downturn is nothing more than a small blip caused by the credit crunch. While the value of college education to the individual is one reason why they are seen as an elite, another reason is the value that these individuals collectively bring to the town or city in which they live. Temple (2000, pp. 1-2) argues that the productivity of a city rises when there is a graduate level institution present, bringing increased wealth to the whole community, and advises third world and transitional economies to invest in education, not just for these strong economic reasons, but also because of the huge social and cultural advantages that come with college education. This advantage in the human capital of a region is not measurable in dollars, but rather in the improved status in the community and quality of life that students have, being able to access many intangible benefits through their skills level and enthusiasm for innovation. What this research shows is that a college education privileges a person in ways that are hard to measure but nevertheless very significant. It proves that collectively, this generation of students enjoys a high status in society. An intriguing part of Brotsoff’s argument relating to the “Occupy Wall Street” relies on parallels with previous periods of student activism relating to the Invasion of Iraq which she somewhat presumptuously labels “our Vietnam.” (Brotsoff, 2011, p. 1) Bruntsoff is willing to admit that the student demonstrations of the Gulf War period were little more than token efforts, quickly organized and just as quickly forgotten when students returned to their usual preoccupation of “crawling deeper into one’s individual cocoon of privilege” (Brotsoff, 2011, p.1). What the author does not realize is that the adoption of protest stances in youth is a phenomenon which derives largely from a psychological need to follow the example of their parents (Duncan and Stewart, 1995, p.914). The protest is for younger people not so much an act of political engagement, as a rite of passage which has become traditional in a section of society which has the luxury, and the prior role models, to engage in such gestures. It belongs to student transitional life as much as all night essay marathons and the rigors of the examination process. Far from being a sincere and well-argued theoretical position, Brotsoff’s piece is a petulant plea for the right to have the culturally important moment of fame that the Woodstock generation had with their flower power and love-in events. The argument that Brotsoff makes is simple, and quite astonishing in its crass materialism and selfishness. The “grievances” that she complains about are loss of privileges that had been implicitly promised in the elitist education process that she and her peers had taken on board, in the hope of huge advantages in later life. She argues that “prospects for recent graduates are declining” (Brotsoff, 2011, p. 1) and cites a median starting salary for graduates some 10 per cent less than those who graduated a year earlier, as if there is some universal law that should protect college graduates from the global financial crises that have devastated salary and employment levels on a scale unprecedented since the Great Depression of the 1920s. Bruntshoff appeal based on an economic victim status for graduates is not justifiable. The truth is that graduates are more protected than any other sector of the population because they have the benefit of a greater skills base with which to engineer a career change when conditions are difficult. Those who have only high school qualifications and a vocational training fare much worse in hard times, because they are more closely tied in to just one area of employment. The narrow focus of this article, on preserving the privileges of the few, does not support its contention that the wall street protestors are genuinely progressive reformers, but proves rather the opposite. The whole event is little more than “a vacation for spoiled brats” (Bruntshoff, 2011, p.1) who lack solidarity with other sectors of society, and are following their parents’ footsteps into the limelight and out of any serious contribution to the future of America. References Brotsoff, Marissa. “When student is an occupation: Caught in an economic quagmire, the educated class turns to OWS” Salon website. Available at: http://www.salon.com/2011/10/28/when_student_is_an_occupation/ Bureau of Labor Statistics. “Earnings by educational attainment and sex, 1979 and 2002”. October 23, 2003. Available online at: http://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2003/oct/wk3/art04.htm Duncan, Lauren E. and Stewart, Abigail J. “Still Bringing the Vietnam War Home: Sources of Contemporary Student Activism. Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 21 No. 9 (1995), pp. 914-924. Temple, Jonathan. “Growth effects of education and social capital in the OECD countries,” OECD Economic Studies, 2000. Available online at: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=276787 Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“When student is an occupation: Caught in an economic quagmire, the Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1434326-when-student-is-an-occupation-caught-in-an-economic-quagmire-the-educated-class-turns-to-ows
(When Student Is an Occupation: Caught in an Economic Quagmire, the Essay)
https://studentshare.org/english/1434326-when-student-is-an-occupation-caught-in-an-economic-quagmire-the-educated-class-turns-to-ows.
“When Student Is an Occupation: Caught in an Economic Quagmire, the Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1434326-when-student-is-an-occupation-caught-in-an-economic-quagmire-the-educated-class-turns-to-ows.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF When student is an occupation: Caught in an economic quagmire, the educated class turns to OWS

The Making of A Quagmire

A broad-based, educated leadership is the only solution.... Order#: 541251 Topic: The Making of A quagmire America must stay in Afghanistan I categorically state that America must stay in Afghanistan.... Order 541251 Topic: The Making of A quagmire America must stay in Afghanistan I categorically that America must stay in Afghanistan.... Works Cited Halberstam, David: The Making of A quagmire: America and Vietnam; McGraw-Hill Humanities/Social Sciences/Languages; 1 edition, October 1, 1987....
3 Pages (750 words) Assignment

Providing Community Service Through Occupation

The community is primarily rural to middle class citizens.... Running head: COMMUNITY SERVICE INTERVIEW Providing Community Service Through occupation Name School Affiliation Providing Community Service Through occupation When one thinks of community service occupations the jobs that may first come to mind are doctors, nurses, teachers, county prosecutors, mayors, public officials, policemen, and many others.... This paper is written with the intention to introduce Kenneth Dudley (personal communication, November 3, 2011) and describe his contributions of community service through his occupation as a school superintendent....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Occupational Analysis of a High School History Teacher

He always had his notebook with him that was helpful in case he was going from one-grade class to another.... Understanding the social organization of the teaching occupation is imperative for the identification of rewarding strategies of an organization.... when I was around, the teacher went to a staff meeting where he, later on, told me that they had discussed the various means through which they would make teaching more habitable....
9 Pages (2250 words) Research Paper

Occupation Is Central to the Practice of Occupational Therapy

occupation can best be described as human activity that is acted out with purpose within a space, and that has meaning for the actor (Blair, 2000; Christiansen & Townsend, 2003).... Occupational therapists encourage and support the use of occupation as a method of promoting rapid health gains, and of enhancing existing health and well-being.... hellip; It is recognized by occupational therapists that the awareness of the conscious intentions and goals of an individual as they carry out their occupation will provide understanding of the purposive influences of the occupation for the person (Christiansen & Townsend, 2003; Fisher, 1998). The following paper will focus on the importance of occupation as defined within the discipline of occupational therapy....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

What is the best way to educate the U.S. workforce

They are distracted in class, working after school at low paying, part time jobs where everything of value is generally learnt within a short period of time and they stay on for purely financial reasons.... The other side of the same coin is the “massification” of education with student base expansion since the 1980s [Alexander,...
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Class Economics of Race and Gender

These opinions can This class, Economics of Race and Gender has helped me understand how important diversity is to a country and the businesses that operate in that country.... These presentations encourage discussions in class and students can question their fellow students more easily then they can question the professor.... Other students may become complacent and not take an interest in the class.... The three movies presented in class were: Freedom Writers, Rossie the Riveter and Crash....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Role of Gender Stereotypes in Choice of Occupation

This  paper "The Role of Gender Stereotypes in Choice of occupation" seeks to investigate the effect that gender stereotypes have on both male and female career preferences.... Conclusion: The influence of gender stereotypes on career choices can be significantly reduced if the decision is made based on the preferred aspects or characteristics of one's future occupation, rather than the career itself, which is likely to be biased by gender stereotypes....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Educational Role of Occupation Therapy

… The paper "Educational Role- occupation Therapy" is a good example of an essay on education.... This report is about the educational role I have chosen to help international occupation therapy (OT) students at Deakin University.... The paper "Educational Role- occupation Therapy" is a good example of an essay on education.... This report is about the educational role I have chosen to help international occupation therapy (OT) students at Deakin University....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us