StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Legal-business auto accidents - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Author [Manager] Legal-Business 24 November 2015 AUTO-ACCIDENTS GEIER V. AMERICAN HONDA MOTOR CO. 529 US 861 I. Introduction In a recent news report of the New York Times dated February 23, 2011, the family of a woman who was killed in car accident due to a “head-on collision sued the car maker of the mini-van that she was driving for its failure to install lap-and-shoulder belts…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.5% of users find it useful
Legal-business auto accidents
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Legal-business auto accidents"

Download file to see previous pages

Honda Motor Company, “where the court ruled that the regulation foreclosed the filing of injury suits under the state law by the people contending that manufacturers had made the wrong choice” (Liptak). II. Facts of the Case: Petitioner, Alexis Geier, was driving a 1987 Honda Accord, which collided in a tree and caused the petitioner serious physical injuries, despite the fact that the shoulder and lap belts were fastened at the time the accident happened. The car was not also equipped with airbags.

Petitioner, together with her parents, sued American Honda Motor Company, Inc. before the District of Columbia tort law, on the ground that Honda negligently was remiss in its obligation as a car manufacturer for failure to set an airbag at the driver’s side. The Court dismissed the case on the ground that it was the discretion of Honda to whether or not install an airbag in its car models. Hence, this ruling concluded that it was not mandatory for the automakers to install a passenger-side airbag, and shall not be liable for a personal injury case based on such ground.

The Court of Appeals reaffirmed the decision of the District Court which resulted to a dismissal of the case. Thus, an appeal to the Supreme Court was filed by the petitioners. . s in conflict with the existing provisions of FMVS 208 Act, particularly on the express pre-emption provision Ruling: The Supreme Court ruled that: With regard to the first issue, the court held that the ordinary principles of pre-emption shall not apply in the case of the petitioners. The provision contained in the Act states that the federal safety standard does not relieve a person from any liability on the basis of the common law.

Hence, the petitioners are not precluded from setting up a claim against American Honda. The language of the provision clause enacted by Congress does not prohibit common-law actions. The spirit of the law must be followed and not its literal meaning of the law. In case of doubt, the intention of the law must prevail over the strict context of the law. Thus, “express pre-emption provision that excludes common-law tort actions gives actual meaning to the saving clause’s literal language, while leaving adequate room for state tort law to operate” (Cornell).

For the second issue, the Court held that ordinary pre-emption principles apply in the case of the petitioners. In its decision, the Court anchored its conclusion on the basis of “the express pre-emption and saving provisions when taken together, shall create a “special burden,” which a court must impose “on a party” who claims conflict pre-emption under those principles. A “special burden” would also promise practical difficulty by further complicating well-established pre-emption principles that already are difficult to apply” (Cornell).

In one of the dissent of the justices, one justice commented that if the “special burden” would be made applicable in such a case, where the state law penalizes the requirement of the federal law which is an absolute

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Legal-business auto accidents Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1416397-legal-business-auto-accidents
(Legal-Business Auto Accidents Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1416397-legal-business-auto-accidents.
“Legal-Business Auto Accidents Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1416397-legal-business-auto-accidents.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Legal-business auto accidents

Product Liability Suit - the Recall Case of Toyota Company

The paper "Product Liability Suit - the Recall Case of Toyota Company" states that the reputation of Toyota Motor Company was already tainted because of their failure to address the staggering incidence of product liability cases and economic downturns hurled by domestic and global markets.... nbsp;… Edmunds....
11 Pages (2750 words) Case Study

General Car Safety and Different Age Groups

Nowadays, there are many features (like airbags and special brakes) provided in standard family saloon cars that provide protection from major accidents, but to a limit.... This complex setup of brakes makes it very easy for the driver to stop the car; thus, any error in this system is a major cause of life-taking accidents.... Although they are a lifesaver in major accidents, they have been known to easily injure the passenger.... Loss of grip can be a cause of major accidents....
23 Pages (5750 words) Essay

Problem of Road Accident Deaths in Ireland

Road accidents are a major cause of death in Ireland.... It is a fact that road accidents are a common problem everywhere in the world, but it is the regulations and the level of efficiency of various law enforcement divisions in Ireland which play an extremely crucial role in minimizing road related deaths and avoidable accidents to begin with.... The speed for traveling motorists is extremely high and concretes the growing problem of accidents taking place on the highways (RTE News 2006)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Insurance: The Imposition of Persistency Discount

The critics have cautioned that persistency discount will put the owner in a web of other charges in form of automobile insurance, the penalty for accidents - irrespective of their fault; the concerns are specifically valid for motorists.... The paper contains a discussion that persistency discount was a trap if the customer has to secure this benefit than the customer has to commit its long-term affiliation with the insurer....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Study for Insurance Covers

One morning for knowing the cause of water leaks in the room he climbs up into the roof and find that it is caused by a defective hot water system that will need replacing.... On his way back to the manhole he… ps and results in the scratch of side board .... n addition to the side board being scratched a crystal vase on the side board breaks when it is knocked to the floor ....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

The History of Toyota Corporation

Two testimonies, however, blamed the accidents to electrical malfunction with testimonial reports and personal testing and analysis.... Any investigation on the sudden acceleration accidents could have been influenced and biased due to connections with Toyota.... Also at risk are the public who could be victims of these kinds of car accidents.... Further, in all humility, Toyota, through its senior officers, including the grandson of the founder, Aiko Toyoda, expressed their sympathies to the victims and support that the investigations would ultimately reveal facts on the root cause of the accidents....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Mandatory Vehicle Insurance

As the frequency of the motor vehicles' accidents increased, it became necessary for the automobiles to be regulated by laws.... The auto insurance is aimed at covering the risk of financial liability.... Due to the significance of the auto insurance, drawing on a variety of sources the paper will discuss why it is fair mandate for all the 50 states to require that all the automobile owners to provide a minimum for an auto insurance so as to enjoy the state-guaranteed privilege of driving that vehicle within the state....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Legal Position of the Cases

This study "Legal Position of the Cases" examines two particular cases regarding the application of business law.... The study firstly briefly outlines the facts and background of each case.... Furthermore, the writer would provide a legal analysis along with conclusive recommendations.... hellip; According to Sir William Anson “Acceptance is to offer what a lighted match is to a train of gun powder”....
20 Pages (5000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us