StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Accounting and the Public Sector - Who Measures What and Why - Literature review Example

Cite this document
Summary
There are several studies in accounting that have emphasized on the introduction of accounting system in the public sector for sustaining and enforcing the mechanism of competition-based resource allocation…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
Accounting and the Public Sector - Who Measures What and Why
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Accounting and the Public Sector - Who Measures What and Why"

?Accounting and the Public Sector - Who Measures What and Why? Table of Contents Introduction 3 Review 3 Conclusion 6 Reference List 7 Introduction There are several studies in accounting that have emphasized on the introduction of accounting system in the public sector for sustaining and enforcing the mechanism of competition-based resource allocation. Public sector organizations have also introduced development measurement system and methodologies of performance improvement in order to demonstrate higher accountability. There has been a shift in the emphasis of the control from process and input to output control. The performance orientation is one of the major elements in the new public management concepts and the explicit standards for the performance measurement are seen to support this diffusion of new concepts. This study aims towards conducting a literature review of accountability in public sector. Review Catasu?s and Gro?nlund (2005) have conducted research on the accountability and measurement on the Swedish Armed Forces. There is a scale down observed in the Swedish public sectors and they are aiming to create a resemblance with the other European nations. New ideologies and organizational forms are replacing the welfare state, which emphasizes on the probity, process and managerial accountability. This dismantling of the division between the private and public allows the private sector discourses to be informed to the public administrative practices. “Reinvent” is the recent effort taken by the government in emphasizing the role played by measurement system in enhancing the effectiveness and efficiency of the governmental operations. However, the fundamental question still remains there, that is, whether the notion of accountability and performance management, which is followed in the private sector, is applicable to the public sector. This indicates towards the fundamental differences that exist between the public and the private sector. In recent year’s advanced development system and performance enhancement methodologies were implemented in the public sector, which showed higher degree of accountability. Therefore, the main aim of the research was to conduct an analysis of the changing accountability by evaluating the changes in the measurements. Thus, the study focused at the relationship between accountability and measurement by highlighting on the measurement. Another study regarding the unintended or intended outcome of performance measurement in the public sector was conducted by Adcroft and Willis (2005). In this context the study highlights on the regimes of performance management that fits to the purpose of the public sector and the intended outcomes for the public services and the workers of the public sector of the performance measurement system. The key issues that are answered by the research is that content or the text of performance management in the public sector with examples specific to the higher education and healthcare; the intended outcome and the limitation of the performance management system. While most of the literatures have emphasized on the introduction of accounting system in the public sector organization of the developed countries that would lead to organizational and cultural exploration, the research scholars Ballas and Tsoukas (2004) has raised the question regarding why the accounting system are not used in public bureaucracies, which should have implemented much before. In order to find the answer of this question, the study has focused on the absence of accounting and lack of systematic measurement in a public bureaucracy. The study has explored and explained the absence of developed accounting system in the Greek National Health System and compared with the Greek political system. The paradigm of the new public management is based on the central belief that the public service organizations should not only be accountable to the fiduciary matters but should be accountable to the objectives and the efficiencies too. A cluster of administrative values is seen to permeate the organizations. In today’s, public sector organizations, all types of accounting standards are required; some accountability system are connected to the measurement systems while some to the daily rules and routines. Catasu?s and Gro?nlund (2005) in their research have found that in Swedish Air force all types of accountability and measurement systems are incorporated. Omega accountability is also present in the Swedish Air Force. This indicates that the principal is having a weak link in the accountability relationship in a situation where the measurement agenda is in the hands of the agent. The problems are seemed to cross the limits of output and performance and are creating challenges for the public sector. Adcroft and Willis (2005) in their article have argued that the most common outcome of increased usage of performance measurement in the public sector organization is commodification of services that are delivered by the deprofessionalised workforce of the public sector. This outcome has been argued in the article because of two reasons. Firstly, there is a huge range of management and technical issues with the performance management system of the public sector that makes it unfit for the purpose. Secondly, there is large amount of difficulty in implementing management practices from the private to the public sector. Adcroft and Willis (2005) have suggested that the performance measurement system in the public sectors is less likely to create a significant impact on the enhancing the services. The intended outcome of the system is deprofessionalisation of the workers in the public sector and commodification of the services. However, the measurement system is seen to strongly impact the behavior of the managers. If the performance measurement system creates beneficial result then it worth investments by the organization. However, the experience of such system outside the public sector enterprise creates a less optimum outcome where the struggle within the organization is not compensated by the gains of the customers who are present outside. On the other hand, the finding of the research scholars Ballas and Tsoukas (2004) has suggested that the Greek political system is characterized by high politicization that tends to overshadow the managerial cum economic dimension of running the public bureaucracy, favoring the political evaluation of the organization as well as the individual performance. In such a situation, accounting system is seen to depict a low symbolic significance and its use creates marginal contribution towards the enhancement of organizational legitimacy. Conclusion The overall review suggests that performance measurement system is seen to crease a weak link with the accountability in a public sector organization. It is seen that it tends to create deprofessionalism among the workers and commoditize the services. Therefore, the impact of the performance management system is quite marginal. On the other hand, in countries where there is a high dominance of the political system, the political evaluation of the organizational outcome gains prevalence and overshadows the economic and managerial dimension. Reference List Adcroft, A. and Willis, R., 2005. The (un)intended outcome of public sector performance measurement. International Journal of Public Sector Management, 18(5), pp.386 – 400. Ballas, A.A. and Tsoukas, H., 2004. Measuring nothing: The case of the Greek National Health System. Human Relations, 57(6), pp. 661–690. Catasu?s, B. and Gro?nlund, A., 2005. More peace for less money: measurement and accountability in the Swedish Armed Forces. Financial Accountability & Management, 21(4), pp. 0267-4424. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Accounting and the Public Sector - Who Measures What and Why Literature review”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1487097-accounting-and-the-public-sector-who-measures-what
(Accounting and the Public Sector - Who Measures What and Why Literature Review)
https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1487097-accounting-and-the-public-sector-who-measures-what.
“Accounting and the Public Sector - Who Measures What and Why Literature Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1487097-accounting-and-the-public-sector-who-measures-what.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Accounting and the Public Sector - Who Measures What and Why

Management Accounting Issues

This observation is in line with what Chandler (1977) set out, when he maintained that modern management originated from the economic history.... In addition, another important contributor of the modern management, just as Chandler maintained, is George Whistler who was associated with the Western Railroad.... Management accounting [University] [Instructor Name] MANAGEMENT accounting Administrative Coordination – Chandler Chandler (1977) suggested that Management Information System is one of the results of the scope and scale that business is conducted....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Key Features of Public and Private Sector Organisations

There are many private companies providing services similar to the public sector services; they all compete for customers and resources, as well as market for their products and services.... Differences between Private and Public Companies Organisation level One factor that characterizes the public sector is the many formal processes that must be in place to make such an organisation function appropriately (ESADE, 2011).... the public sector has to provide...
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Performance Measurement in Public Sector

This term paper "Performance Measurement in public sector" describes an understanding of performance measurement systems and their effectiveness in enhancing employee performance and discusses the way this system should be implemented so as to achieve desired outcomes.... Due to the fact that most public sector organizations do not operate for profit motives, these organizations cannot set performance goals on the basis of achievement of profit targets....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

Public Sector Organizations

The paper 'Public Sector Organizations' presents the public sector which differs from the private sector on several fronts which is due to the basic difference in the structure and functions of both the sectors.... One more important factor to be kept in mind is that the performance of the public sector unit will directly contribute to the country's economy.... In addition, the reforms in the public sector are needed for the following factors which also decide the style of financial reporting in public enterprises....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Coalition for Environmentally Responsible Economies - the Balanced Scorecard

nbsp; The reason why the Balanced Scorecard notion has so extensively accepted by manufacturing and service companies, nonprofit institutions, and government bodies globally since its opening in 1992: First, preceding methods that included non financial measurements use unplanned gathering of such measure, for instance, checklist of measures for manager to follow of and improve than an inclusive system of related measurements.... The close link between the measurement method and strategy raises the role of non-financial measures from a set checklist to a complete system for strategy accomplishment (Kaplan, Norton, 1996a) Second, The Balanced Scorecard mirror the shifting nature of technology and aggressive benefit of the 19th and much of 20th centuries, corporations attained viable benefit from their investment in and running of tangible assets such as inventory, property, plant, and equipment (Chandler, 1990)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Public Sector and Management Accounting

A Critical Evaluation of the International Public Sector Accounting Standards Board (IPSASB) and the Conceptual Framework of the International Public Sector Accounting Standards (IPSAS) as a Standard Setting Body in the public sector the public sector comes with a different… This is because the public sector exists to help the members of the society and carry out governments policies.... However, the public sector has distinct requirements and expectations....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Gap Analysis - Its Implication for Private and Public Sectors

An assessment of their value will enable the researcher to reach conclusions about what system may apply in diverse situations and contexts.... The gap analysis will enable the strategic planner to determine what needs to be done – whether it be scaling down the targets, acquiring the means to bridge the gap or a combination of both.... Basically, the gap analysis concept attempts to assess where the firm is today compared to where it would like to be in some future time and to determine the gap that must be filled to reach its goal through what he termed as "gap-reducing actions....
20 Pages (5000 words) Research Paper

The Introduction of Public Bodies and Intergovernmental Organizations

Agencies, whether public sector or private corporation, promote fair and open competition to minimize deception and complicity.... hellip; Nowadays the public procurement system is one of the highly sensitive financial issues.... Till then, it was regarded as a clerical purchasing part of the business in the public sectors.... n the present scenario, the public procurement system is one of the basic financial needs of the government and corporate sectors....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us