StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Andrew Jackson vs. Henry Clay - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
An author of this paper will reveal his thoughts on the activity of two known politicians: Andrew Jackson and Henry Clay. In retrospect, both men were doing what they thought was correct for the nation at the time but went about it in a different way…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
Andrew Jackson vs. Henry Clay
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Andrew Jackson vs. Henry Clay"

Andrew Jackson and Henry Clay were both well-known politicians in the course of United States history, often because of their differing views on politics and policy. Both had strong wills and even stronger ideals about the way that the country should be run, advocating different paths for the growth and development of the country. Both men had the power to curry favor with various politicians. Both came into politics during the 1820s, an era when the United States was growing rapidly, voters had increased, and the country was trying to find out and come into its own as a country, still leaving behind the stigma of once being a colony of Great Britain while establishing itself as a world power (Davidson, and Stoff 330). Both men also served in the War of 1812, with Andrew Jackson commanding forces at New Orleans and Henry Clay acting as a War Hawk from Kentucky (Davidson, and Stoff 333). However, it was through their political sparring and verbal fencing that Jackson and Clay would gain historical fame, each man trying to defend their views of what they thought best for the country. Clay supported a strong federal government with what he called the “American System”, a system of proposals that would have meant a national bank and high tariffs, along with using sale proceeds from public lands to finance improved roadways and canals, while Andrew Jackson supported the opposite, calling for a federal government with limited powers, lower tariffs, and a banking system that would be controlled by gold and silver, not paper banknotes, but most importantly, it would belong to the states. Henry Clay, in short, advocated a path for the development of America that would have kept power in the hands of the federal government, with very little of that power belonging to any state, while Jackson advocated for the rights of states and their citizens. Both Clay and Jackson are remembered for what is commonly known as the Bank War. Henry Clay was a staunch supporter for the Bank of the United States, and he incorporated the bank into his American System, by “interlocking” it with all stages of the proposals, including high tariffs and land sales (Watson 83). Andrew Jackson, however, did not only hate the bank, but he also loathed the bank. First and foremost, he thought that the bank was far too powerful, as well as undemocratic, as it was controlled by private bankers (Davidson, and Stoff 335). Even after Congress renewed the charter, Jackson vetoed it harshly, stating that only states should charter banks, not the federal government (Davidson, and Stoff 335). With the power of the presidential office behind Jackson, Henry Clay had lost a great proposal piece of his American System, and Jackson had asserted his authority to keep power in the hands of the states. Jackson and Clay both waged another type of war, over tariffs, which caused both men political agony. Clay was in favor of high tariffs, especially on imported goods, using those tariffs to protect domestic, or American-made, products and manufacturers (Watson 21). American manufacturers were considered to be a profitable competition for British manufacturers, and Clay wanted nothing more than to see America produce all of the goods that it needed on its own (Heidler, and Heidler 125). It soon became clear, though, that the South hated the tariff, as it put taxes on everything that they had to buy, and nothing of what they had to sell (Brands 433). The tariffs threatened rifts within the nation at a time when they could not be afforded; South Carolina even threatened nullification, or the right to refuse the tariff, as they thought it was unconstitutional (Davidson, and Stoff 337). Jackson, as a Southerner, did not care for the high tariffs, but as a politician, he knew his stance must be careful; therefore, he advocated an approach that would keep the interests of the country at the forefront, and stated that most of his sympathies lay with the agricultural aspects, not the manufacturing aspects (Brands 433). In a spectacular, double-edged move, he supported a compromise tariff that would lower the tariffs, but asked Congress to pass a “Force Bill”, which would allow him army support to enforce tariffs in South Carolina (Davidson, and Stoff 338). Tariffs became lower, to the great relief of the nation, but tensions between Jackson and Clay were far from over. One other big issue at hand, that affected the whole nation, was what to do with the proceeds from tracts of land held for sale throughout the country. Clay advocated and promoted a system that he referred to as distribution, whereby those proceeds were put back into federal funding for use in building and modernizing roadways and canals (Watson 85). Congress even sent his land redistribution bill to Jackson for signature; however, the way it was presented was alongside the Force Bill, making it seem as though Jackson had to sign one to have the other (Heidler, and Heidler 255). Jackson willingly signed the Force Bill, but used the extraordinary measure of “pocket veto” on the land bill (Heidler, and Heidler 245). Henry Clay had, therefore, lost the last part of his American System, and Jackson prevailed overall. In retrospect, both men were doing what they thought was correct for the nation at the time, but went about it in a different way. It is my opinion that Henry Clay was more successful over the long term, because he had the national interests at heart, and not just his own personal views. There can be no doubt that the nation needed what Clay was proposing; new roadways would have helped commerce, and a national bank would have helped avoid, rather than precipitate, the panics that were brought on by land speculation and purchase. Looking around today, the success of Henry Clay is plain in the interstate roadways and the banking system of the nation, while Jackson is remembered only as a roaring bully who loved his veto power. Both Clay and Jackson, while being bitter political rivals, had the interests of the nation at heart. Though they took widely different paths to see those interests realized, they both deserve a place in the books of history as venerable, successful politicians, who were not afraid to stand up for what they believed in and what they felt the nation could achieve. Works Cited Brands, H.W. Andrew Jackson: His Life and Times. First Anchor Books Edition. New York: Doubleday, 2006. Print. Davidson, James W., and Michael B. Stoff. The American Nation. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1998. Print. Heidler, David S., and Jeanne T. Heidler. Henry Clay: The Essential American. First Edition. New York : Random House, Inc., 2010. Print. Watson, Harry L. Andrew Jackson vs. Henry Clay: Democracy and Development in Antebellum America (The Bedford Series in History and Culture). Boston, MA: Palgrave Macmillan, 1998. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Andrew Jackson vs. Henry Clay Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1435478-andrew-jackson-vs-henry-clay
(Andrew Jackson Vs. Henry Clay Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/history/1435478-andrew-jackson-vs-henry-clay.
“Andrew Jackson Vs. Henry Clay Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1435478-andrew-jackson-vs-henry-clay.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Andrew Jackson vs. Henry Clay

U.S. History : Jacksonian symbolism

Although andrew jackson symbolized the emergence of the common man, the essence of his presidency can be found by looking at his policies in the areas such as nullification, the spoils system, Indian removal and the Bank War.... History : Jacksonian symbolism While Jacksonian democracy emerged to promote the rule of the ‘mass' and the ‘common' of America, the policies that substantiated jackson's regime and their impact apparently became the chief determinants that aid in the assessment of his presidency and the truth of its underlying principles....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

A Dialogue between Andrew Jackson and Henry Clay

Andrew Jackson and henry clay.... Similarly, henry clay is also regarded to be a considerable personality in the early history of America, who served as senator, speaker of the House of Representatives and US Secretary of State, who demonstrated his diplomatic skills while serving at the same position.... hellip; From this paper, it is clear that andrew jackson serves as one of the most influential statesmen the USA has ever produced.... andrew jackson serves as one of the most influential statesmen the USA has ever produced....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper

Polarizing Leadership of Andrew Jackson

In drafting his policies concerning this issue, the president expressed his plan to challenge the constitutionality of the bank for which Nicholas Biddle, the bank's director applied his own political power summoning the aid of Congress officials, which included the powerful Kentucky Senator henry clay and some influential businessmen who understood Biddle's cause to stand against the president.... As a president who committed himself to being a ‘common man' or man of the people, andrew jackson established policies for which his leadership received either revering loyalty of the mass or reviling hostility of those who could not take their intended advantage of his principles and relation....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Election of 1828

He (Andrew Jackson) and his loyalist were outraged when the House of Representatives because of the influence henry clay, an unsuccessful presidential candidate and speaker of the house, awarded the presidency to John Quincy Adams.... One may wonder if the process was free and fair and totally unbiased as a few days later, the president-elect John Quincy Adams named henry clay his secretary of state4.... The historical race involved the incumbent, John Quincy Adams, and the once-defeated andrew jackson....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

In What Ways Were Racial Tensions Intensified in the South During the Jackson Era

The followers of John Quincy Adams and henry clay, who demanded that the federal government still required putting more efforts in a developing economy, became known as National Republicans (Remini 143).... Half-way his second term, the rebelling group defected from the party, and became known as the Whig Party led by henry clay and Daniel Webster.... The followers of andrew jackson, Democratic-Republicans, became Democratic in 1828.... social structure gradually resulted into the creation of new political alignments within a one-party system… The changes that occurred during this time include; the agrarian revolution in the southern states, which led to increased slavery especially in the cotton farms, and the development of the nation westwards, that mainly comprised of pioneer farmers whose community was “The jackson's Era” In chapter 4 of A Short History of the United s, Remini describes a series of events and changes that occurred during jackson's tenure....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The Market Economy in Jacksonian America. Did it benefit or hurt america

In the year 1834, President andrew jackson was celebrating the “glorious victory.... He confidently proclaimed himself to be the common man champion and he believed that their interests were ignored by the aggressive national economic plans of and Adams and clay.... This is more than double the turnout in 1824; he clearly headed a… He warned that the nation had been corrupted by "special honor," characterized especially by the policies of the Second ranked Bank of According to jackson, the proper road to reform lay in an absolute acceptance of majority rule as was expressed through the democratic process....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

Andrew Jackson, Rise to Power

This paper describes jackson's, the seventh president of the United States of America and served two terms in office, early life and his journey towards the presidency as well as briefly providing a description of his life after being elected president… To sum up, jackson's presidency left a substantial mark on US politics that still carries through today.... jackson's legacy was definitely in the formation of the Democratic Party.... jackson's father passed away before his birth forcing his mother to move jackson and his two brothers, Robert, and Hugh in with some relatives (Baililes, n....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Andrew Jacksons Presidency

He won the election in 1828 by defeating henry clay who was opposing Jackson.... He won the election in 1828 by defeating henry clay who was opposing Jackson.... … The paper "andrew jackson's Presidency" is a wonderful example of a history essay.... andrew jackson served as the President of United States of America from the year 1828-1837.... The paper "andrew jackson's Presidency" is a wonderful example of a history essay....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us