StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

African American strugle for recognition - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The African American struggle for recognition, identity and acceptance as part of the human race may, quite accurately, be used to summarize the general premise of both Richard Wright's "Big Good Black Man," and Ralph Ellison's "Battle Royal." …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.2% of users find it useful
African American strugle for recognition
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "African American strugle for recognition"

The African American struggle for recognition, identity and acceptance as part of the human race may, quite accurately, be used to summarize the general premise of both Richard Wright's "Big Good Black Man," and Ralph Ellison's "Battle Royal." Both stories expose the struggle which African Americans confront as they try to operate within the confines of societies which persistently perceive of them through the racial lens. Ellison's protagonist is confronted with the imperatives of having to prove his individuality and having to enter into a battle royal in order to be granted a college scholarship and, thus, the chance to become someone. Wright's protagonist has to prove himself a human being and, indeed, all his actions, words and attitudes are continually compared to the norm for determination of whether he is a man or beast. Both protagonists are viewed as quasi-human because of their skin color and, accordingly, their struggle, whether consciously or unconsciously taken, begins from point zero. The implication here is that theirs is a struggle to establish that which non-blacks take for granted; the struggle to achieve societal recognition of their humanity and establish their individuality. Racism, as both authors communicate, contests their humanity, their manhood and individuality. Proceeding from the aforementioned, this essay will critically compare and contrast the primary theme, setting and viewpoint of either story in order to illustrate how each author deals with the topic of race. Although both stories appear to adopt race as their primary theme, a close critical reading of "Big Good Black Man" and "Battle Royal" indicates that race is the general topic of both, rather than their theme. Instead, the primary theme in both "Battle Royal" and "Big Good Black Man" is the struggle to affirm identity and confirm humanity within the context of societies which perceive of members of the black race as sub-human or alien to the norm. Both Wright and Ellison portray racial tensions and race relations in terms of a search for identity and the redefinition of manhood. To be recognized as someone and to have his humanity acknowledged, Ellison's protagonist lived by his grandfather's advice: "Live with your head in the lion's mouth. I want you to overcome 'em with yeses, undermine 'em with grins, agree 'em to death and destruction, let 'em swoller you till they vomit or bust wide open" (Ellison, p. 938). He submitted whenever he had to, even agreeing to engage in a "battle royal" to gain a place at university and prove himself someone, a man. In other words, he adopted an insidious persona, appearing unassuming and unthreateningly and, importantly, accepting of societal definitions of his own self while, in fact, he was accepting of none of the stated and was motivated by the determination to become someone, establish his individuality and impose his unquestioned humanity upon his surrounding society. Similarly, Wright's protagonist, whether he does so consciously or not, has to prove himself a man, rather than a black thing. Jim, whose appearance is antithetical to all that which Olaf associates with mankind, must establish himself as a man through action, words, behavior and attitude. His sheer blackness is such that Olaf simply cannot accept him as human. Within the context of the stated, the theme is similarly the affirmation of humanity and identity within the parameters of a societal which is incapable of recognizing him as such simply because of his skin color. The implication here is that both works of fiction delve into the topic of race to portray the extent to which the reluctance of the Other to accept alternate types of manhood and humanity as legitimate provoke a search for identity and the redefinition of manhood. The settings of both stories are also comparable because the locus of action in both is, whether figuratively or literally, a boxing ring. In Ellison's "Battle Royal" the protagonist is called upon to affirm his humanity, confirm his manhood and establish his worth by entering into a boxing ring. The setting is, thus, an overtly antagonistic and confrontational one. The same is true for "Big Good Black Man." Set in the northern-most reaches of Europe, the land of blue-eyed, blonde and pale beings, Jim whose "skin was so black that it had a bluish tint," emerges as the incontrovertible antagonist (Wright, p. 207). Within the context of the stated, the hotel becomes the boxing ring. It is the arena where Olaf and Jim spar and throw punches at one another, each trying to establish his manhood, his being and, ultimately, his supremacy over the other. Both settings are, in other words, overtly antagonistic and, as such, reflective of the undertones of racial tension which run throughout the two stories. The points of view expressed in both stories are also comparable insofar as they revolve around the definition of the self vis--vis the other. In Ellison's story the narrator, who is also the protagonist, tells his story within the constraints of an I' and them' viewpoint. From the very first lines, readers are confronted with the fact that the narrator's point of view is determined by his perception of others and his assumption regarding Others' perceptions of him. As he says from the outset, "all my life I have been looking for something and everywhere I turned someone tried to tell me what it was" " (Ellison, p. 937). As evidenced in the aforementioned quote, the point of view expressed in "Battle Royal" is a reactive one, in the sense that it responds to and is shaped by perceptions of the views of others of the self. The same is true fir Wright's story. The unnamed narrator, expressing Olaf's point of view, similarly confines his perception of the Other from to the I/us' versus Him/them,' dyad. It is, thus, that Olaf's expressed viewpoints of Jim tend towards the depiction of the man as quasi-human, as semi-bestial. This is amply evidenced in several instances throughout the story such as when Olaf thinks that " .. this particular black man Well, he didn't seem human. Too big, too black, too loud, too direct and probably too violent to boot" (Wright, p. 208). The implication here is that the viewpoint in both stories is directly influenced by perceptions of Other-ness or how the protagonists' appearance differs from the supposed norm. Similarities in theme, however, do not negate the presence of obvious differences. In "Battle Royal" the focal theme is the affirmation of identity while in "Big Good Black Man" it is the confirmation of humanity. Ellison's protagonist enters the ring in order to become someone and to prove that he is an individual, not just a faceless, identity-less member of the African American race. As the narrator says, "All my life I was looking for myself It took me a long time and much painful boomeranging of my expectations to achieve a realization which everyone else appears to have been borne with: That I am nobody but myself" (Ellison, p. 937). His entry into the ring is not simply expressive of his determination to become someone but to become someone on his own merits and through his own individual efforts. In this story, the narrator is engaged in a conscious search for self-identity. In direct contrast, Wright's theme appears to be the unconscious affirmation of humanity. Jim shocks Olaf's senses and emerges, not only as antithetical to all that which he associates with human beings but, as a challenge to his points of reference. Jim is not white, yellow or brown but is uncompromisingly and thoroughly black. This means that not does his appearance stand in stark contrast to Olaf's but he challenges Olaf's notion and understanding of race. He is accustomed to yellow, white and brown but Jim is different and is unlike anything Olaf has ever seen. The implication here is that that which Olaf references when defining Man is at odds with Jim's example of Man. Within the context of the stated, the theme revolves around Jim's unconscious establishment of his identity as a man, as a human being. Hence, while the primary concern in "Battle Royal" was the affirmation of individuality, in "A Big Good Black Man," it is confirmation of humanity. Just as is the case with theme, the similarities in setting are balanced by differences. Ellison's story unfolds in pre-Civil Rights America where the humanity of blacks was disputed. In contrast, Wright's story unfolds in post-Civil Rights Europe. Differences in geographic setting are not limited to locale and time but to the general environment within which either story unfolds. Quite simply stated, Wright's protagonist is placed in an environment within which he is incontrovertibly alien. In Copenhagen, Denmark, where the majority of residents are not white but the ultimate expression of that which is Caucasian, Jim's sheer and uncompromising blackness is shocking. Set against the unmitigated whiteness of his surroundings, his skin color immediately identifies him as alien. The setting, in other words, is utilized to establish stark contrasts. This deeply affects the story, insofar as the stark contrasts enabled by the geographic setting, implies that Jim is truly alien to Copenhagen and, accordingly, nothing less than a shock to Olaf's senses and sensibilities. This is hardly true of "Battle Royal" where the protagonist/narrator is native to his environment/setting but is, nevertheless, called upon to prove himself , not just a part of, but worthy of it. While conceding to the fact that whites largely outnumber blacks within the context of the elite setting within which the story unfolds, the fact remains that the protagonist is a minority but an alien, as is Jim. It is geographical settings which have determined, or enabled, the aforementioned. Consequently, differences in setting imply differences in the meaning and implication which either setting brings to the story. Added to the above, similarities in points of view should not obscure the differences between the two. Apart from the most obvious difference, which is that the narrator in Ellison's story is also the protagonist, whereas in "A Good Black Man," he is unnamed and external to the story, sympathetic tendencies differ, or that "A Battle Royal" is told from the perspective of a marginalized black youth who has yet to carve himself an identity and "A Good Black Man" from the perspective of an old retired, frail white sailor whose life is supposedly behind him, there are numerous other differences. The more fundamental of these is that Wright's narrator (or narrator who conveys Olaf's viewpoint) speaks from an embittered perspective while Ellison's narrator speaks from an innocent, as yet hopeful and optimistic perspective. The said differs colors the stories and affects the manner in which either story presents the two African American characters. In one scene, Wright's narrator says " the black mass of power stood still, immobile, looking down at Olaf. Then Olaf sucked in his breath as the devil of blackness commanded him: Stand up!' Olaf tried to rise; then he felt the black paw of the beast then with a slow and deliberate movement of his gorilla like arms, he lifted his mammoth hands to Olaf's throat" (Wright, pp. 211-12). The narrator portrays Jim in bestial, inhuman terms and, in so doing, echoes Olaf's embittered, pessimistic and prejudiced view of life and of the races. In contrast, Ellison's narrator vocalizes a more optimistic perspective. Certainly, engagement in a battle royal for the purposes of being awarded a deserved college scholarship may be demeaning and dehumanizing. Nevertheless, it is conveyed from within the parameters of an optimistic perspective on life. Rather than focus on its demeaning aspect, the narrator highlights the potential promises which a victory could bring. The implication here is that differing points of view do not simply color readers' perspectives on the characters themselves but further directs the plot and the manner of its conveyance, as in whether it is told from an optimistic or a pessimistic viewpoint, a jaundiced or an innocent and hopeful one. Proceeding from the above stated, it is evident that despite similarities, both stories are distinct. The similarities, as explained in the essay, emerge from the racial topic which informs both Wright and Ellison's tales. Accordingly, themes are comparable, in that they may generally be described, or identified, as the search for identity and the affirmation of humanity within the context of racially prejudiced societies. As regards setting, both are similarly comparable in that the hotel, on the one hand, and the boxing ring, on the other, may be defined as arenas of confrontation within the framework of racially prejudiced societies. Lastly, points of view are also somewhat similar given the fact that they are informed by the confrontational, racially prejudiced framework of either story. It is, thus, that the points of view in both are immediately influenced by the notion of the self versus the other. Despite similarities, however, the stories are distinct from one another. Therefore, while themes are comparable they are also unique. Hence, in "Big Good Black Man" the theme is confirmation of humanity while in "Battle Royal" it is affirmation of identity. As regards geographic setting, the stories are obviously different n that the one is set on Copenhagen where the black man bursts on the scene as a distinct oddity, while in the other the setting is pre-civil rights America where blacks, although an inarguable minority, are not as uncommon as they are in the northernmost reaches of Europe. Lastly, points of view differ whereby "Battle Royal" is narrated by a black youth while "A Good Black Man" is narrated by a retired Danish sailor whose life, to all intents and purposes, is behind him. In other words, similarities in all of theme, points of view and setting do not negate the existence of differences. Works Cited Ellison, Ralph. "Battle Royal." Making Literature Matter. Ed. John Schilband John Clifford. Boston: Bedford, 2000. Wright, Richard, "Big Black Good Man". Literature; Reading, Reacting, Writing. Ed. Laurie Kirszner and Stephen Mandell. Boston: Thompson Heinle, 2004. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“African American strugle for recognition Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
African American strugle for recognition Book Report/Review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1521925-african-american-strugle-for-recognition
(African American Strugle for Recognition Book Report/Review)
African American Strugle for Recognition Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/history/1521925-african-american-strugle-for-recognition.
“African American Strugle for Recognition Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1521925-african-american-strugle-for-recognition.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF African American strugle for recognition

Analysis of the Poem What its Like to Be a Black Girl by Patricia Smith

The story of the struggle portrays serious racism and segregation, which makes the girl fight hard to regain recognition in a society that alienates her for being black and different.... The poem “Child of America” by Aurora Morales involves an american coming from various mixtures of cultures, which compromise her real identity and heritage in having a complete identity as an american (McLeod, 1994), and having the privileges of having a pure and traceable background....
34 Pages (8500 words) Essay

Famous African American of the 20th Century

Famous african american of the 20th Century- Martin Luther King   Martin Luther King was born on 15th January 1929 and was assassinated on 4th April 1968 in Memphis, Tennessee.... He recognized that the finest approach to unshackle african american and to give them their rights could be achieved through non violent protests and demonstrations.... Through non violent protests his movement gained recognition and many associates and opened up the way for the passing of Civil Rights Bill in 1964-1965....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Slavery in latin america

The history of Africans in Latin America is unveiled by the author in this book, whereby ideas gathered from slaves' experiences are extended to the present; in fact, this involves an illustration of the history of Africans in six Latin american countries, which include Brazil, Cuba, Mexico, Haiti, Peru and the Dominican Republic.... Context in Which the Book Was Produced The book “Black in Latin America” by Henry Louis Gates was produced in year 2011 to mark a celebration and the will of numerous Haitians and Dominicans to assert their african ancestry....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Struggles of the Native Americans

Some scholars have stated that the natives need the help of influential groups in the society to help them get full recognition by the state and be allowed to enjoy their rights just like any other citizen.... American Indians for instance who are one of the largest communities of native Americans have struggled with to gain recognition from first the European authorities and later on the American Government.... Some scholars have stated that the natives need the help of influential groups in the society to help them get full recognition by the state and be allowed to enjoy their rights just like any other citizen....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Black Diasporic discourse

Every period in the history of african american literature portrays its unique theme.... et,in every period,almost all african american writers have tried to present event a quick look into the diverse and rich histories of African Americans.... hellip; The initial phase of the journey of the African diaspora in the United States was defined by the popularity of the slave narrative, which kept on thriving and influencing african american literature even after the abolition of the institution of slavery....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

African-American psychology

That single-minded desire for self-expression and recognition, was in fact shared by the whole Afro-American people African-American Psychology As I watch James Brown's 'I feel Good' music video, I couldn't help but notice the largely Caucasian audience dancing at the backdrop.... That single-minded desire for self-expression and recognition, was in fact shared by the whole Afro-American people.... Nothing is wrong with singing to an audience of different race per se, but considering the long history of division between the negro people and the whites one can infer that James Brown's decision to do so might have emanated from his deep desire to express his talent at a time when racial segregation was still very much a reality in the american society....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Diamond Trade in Africa

Recounting this history shows how Africa and one f its most marketable resources have become entangled in the values f a cultural polyglot f political economies, and the image f the african suffers in its wake; a diminished ability to claim political representation for many african peoples, and a reduced place f participation in the world economies for african nations and Africa, as a global entity is the result.... (Sherman 600-615) As the image f a "chaotic" Africa persists in the historical moment to de-legitimize it as viable agent in international political economies, divorced f its historical circumstances and left to the whim f market forces and subordinating cultural practices, more and more african peoples come to utilizing force and violence in an effort to attain their participation, perpetuating this tragic image....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

How Have African-Americans Worked to End Segregation to Attain Equality and Civil Rights

Martin Luther King Junior, perhaps one of the most outstanding American statesmen appears synonymous with struggle against segregation by the african american community.... Many other activists across the world had initiated the struggle against discrimination and segregation… Racial discrimination had evolved in the United States to an extent that the african american community had completely been isolated from normal public and social life.... However, this was not to take lace for ever since the spirited struggle against such a corrupt social regime would come to an end and several decades later today, one of the african american descendants is president....
6 Pages (1500 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us