StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

History of Canadian Labor - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The author of the essay entitled "History of Canadian Labor" states that the Laboring class or working class has always been a subject of socio-political interest. Here through our reading of three articles namely “The honest Workingman and Worker’s Contro. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
History of Canadian Labor
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "History of Canadian Labor"

 History of Canadian Labor Laboring class or working class has always been a subject of socio-political interest. Here through our reading of three articles namely “The honest Workingman and Worker’s Control: The Experience of Toronto Skilled Workers’, 1860-1892”, “Joe Beef of Montreal: Working-Class culture and the Tavern, 1869-1889”, and “After the Fur Trade: The Aboriginal Laboring Class of British Columbia 1849-1890” we look at what the writer’s have to say about Canadian laboring class. While giving details of each article we shall compare their subject and come to a conclusion about the Canadian laboring class. The first article, “The honest Workingman and Worker’s Control: The Experience of Toronto Skilled Workers’, 1860-1892”, by Gregory S. Kealey, is an attempt to identify the trends of trade unions during the nineteenth century. The author discusses “Coopers International Union, Ontario No. 3, which played an important role in the Nine Hour Movement and the establishment of the Toronto Trades Assembly; the extensively studied International Typographical Union No. 91; and the Iron Mot-ders International Union No. 28, employed in Toronto's heavily capitalized stove, machinery, and agricultural implements industry” (Kealey). What the author tries to suggest is that the working class was an organized association of trade unions, which had a disciplined way of working, and earnings were fairly decided. The second article, “Joe Beef of Montreal: Working-Class culture and the Tavern, 1869-1889”, by Peter DeLottinville, is a different account of working class in Montreal. The author chooses to represent the working class through a dominant tavern owned by Charles McKiernan, popularly known as ‘Joe Beef’. The book presents a rather different account of the hardships of working class, which were not mentioned in the previous article. Since the article mentions a period that is almost the same as the earlier article, no mention of trade unions is a surprise. Rather the working class is a beer-drinking, rowdy class that finds the middle class suspicious and though there is mention of organized strikes, but the centre of the subject is Joe Beef’s Canteen, which provided the sole entertainment enjoyed by the working class. The author has more to say about Joe Beef than the working class. However, at the same time he has introduced the conditions of working class through a tavern and a man, who the working class people hailed him as their “champion” (DeLottinville). The third article, “After the Fur Trade: The Aboriginal Laboring Class of British Columbia 1849-1890”, by J Lutz, is an attempt to understand the conditions of aboriginals who worked as laborers in British Columbia. He mentions about the worse conditions faced by aboriginal laborers, what he says is that in general term, aboriginal laborers were not faring as well as the other laboring classes were. The labor force was far lower than that for the non-aboriginal population. He introduces us to views that were held by European people about aboriginal laborers. He says that Europeans thought that in spite of doing the labor, the aboriginals were no good when it came to investing and spending, which in turn was the reason for their lower status in the society. Through our reading of the three articles, we can say that in spite of having the same basic subject of working class, the three articles show different approach to the subject. A working class is not just a group of individuals belonging to lower strata of society; instead, even the working class involves people from different societies. Thus, in spite of a similar struggle for more wages and other similar causes, their ideologies and their way of implementing what they want is rather different, which in turn differentiates people in the working class as well. Hence, since the articles also deal with different working classes and different subjects, if we generalize the subject, we cannot say that the articles make the same point or indicate a very different point. Doing that would be difficult since they are in a broader sense indicating the working class as one but when we read the articles in detail, we find significant differences in their situations. From the articles, it is seen that though Peter DeLottinville chooses to suggest that the working class was a drinking class, which was so because they did not have enough money to follow other methods of entertainment. “The culture represented by Joe Beef was certainly different than that of the skilled tradesmen of Montreal. Only with difficulty can one imagine an experienced typographer making regular trips to the Canteen to see the bears. Though rough and respectable cultures interacted, they were clearly separate. The culture surrounding the casual labourers grew out of a physically demanding life of marginal economic benefit, obtained through the common exertion of labour. In these respects, Joe Beefs world was closer to the world of Peter Aylen and the Shiners of the Ottawa Valley than to the typographers in the offices of the Montreal Witness, or the cotton mill workers of Hochelaga” (DeLottinville). On the other hand, this is not what G. S. Kealey has to say. “Skilled workers in the nineteenth century exercised far more power than we have previously realized. Well on into the industrial period craftsmen through their trade unions played important roles in community affairs, in the world of politics and especially on the job. In Toronto work places, craftsmen employed their monopoly on skill and experience to dictate terms to their employers in a wide array of areas which, in modem parlance, gave to these late nineteenth century craftsmen a high degree of workers' control of production” (Kealey). Thus, we see that the articles are different views by three different writers. It is more important to mention here that the different views stem from their viewing of different aspects of the life of a working class man. The articles are a good source to understand how the working class functioned in the nineteenth century. However, if one sits down with the single aim to compare the three articles, not just the reader ends up confused about what exactly is working class culture but also undermines the essentiality of the mentioned articles. It is essential to keep in mind, as mentioned before, that the working class is not a single body. One can safely conclude that the three articles provide an important insight to the working class culture. The three articles are a success in that they do what they mention in their topics. What I mean by that is that instead of involving different aspects of the subject, they chose to stick to the main subject and in doing so, prevented the disaster of a mixing every aspect and not being able to conclude about a single aspect. References DeLottinville, Peter. "Joe Beef of Montreal: Working Class Culture and the Tavern, 1869-1889." Canadian Working Class History: 190-214. Kealey, Gregory S. “The Honest Workingman and Workers’ Control: The Experience of Toronto Skilled Workers, 1860-1892.” Canadian Working Class History: 112-142. Lutz, John. "After the Fur Trade: The Aboriginal Labouring Class of British Columbia, 1849-1890." Journal of the Canadian Historical Association/Revue de la Société historique du Canada 3 (1992): 235-239. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(History of Canadian Labor Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1187 words, n.d.)
History of Canadian Labor Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1187 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1551320-history-of-canadian-labour
(History of Canadian Labor Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1187 Words)
History of Canadian Labor Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1187 Words. https://studentshare.org/history/1551320-history-of-canadian-labour.
“History of Canadian Labor Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1187 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1551320-history-of-canadian-labour.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF History of Canadian Labor

History of Canadian Labour

The author states that the role of unionism in the History of Canadian Labor deserves a special mention.... History of Canadian Labor in the twentieth century is marked by both achievements and setbacks.... he role of unionism in the History of Canadian Labor deserves a special mention.... The author of the paper is going to focus on the initial post-war downturn and the gradual rebuilding of the canadian labor movement in this span of time....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

History of Labor Day in Canada

Another book by one of the authors, Craig Heron's The canadian labor Movement: A Short History has this same famous sweep. On a Sunday evening a century ago this weekend, 14,000 francophone workers gathered on Old Montreal to prepare for Labor Day.... Now two Toronto historians have crafted an illuminating, sometimes offensive retrospective of how labor Day has been marked across Canada.... They show how the labor movement has evolved since the 1880s, along with Canadian society as a whole....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

History of Canadian Labor

hellip; Fifty years later, the Labor revolt in 1919 marked out the dawn of a new era in the history of Canada.... This essay is going to trace the growth and development of the working class people in the history of Canada between 1880 and 1920.... Incepted in 1869 by Philadelphia garment cutters, the Knights of labor was one of the prominent labor reformist organizations in the late nineteenth century.... With the onset of spring, the residents of Winnipeg saw an unprecedented instance of labor unification on matters of common interest....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

History of canadian labour

Bitterman therefore sets out to explore the ‘the importance of wage labour to farm folk in history of canadian labour In his article, Bitterman addresses the myth of the independent yeoman diffused through Maritime literature.... ‘Farm Households and Wage Labour in the Northeastern Maritimes in the Early Nineteenth Century' in canadian Working-class History: Selected Readings.... Toronto: canadian Scholars Press, 2006Bleasdale, Ruth, ‘Class Conflict on the Canals of Upper Canada in the 1840s' in canadian Working-class History: Selected Readings....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

National Identity in a Globalized Canada

This is a historical observation that leads to the evolution of canadian immigration policies.... However seventy-five percent of canadian citizens follow Christianity (“Culture and Religion in Canada”).... There is a fundamental alteration in the history of Marxism and Marxist.... The criteria that they judge includes “countrys policies on labor market mobility, family reunification for third-country nationals, education, political participation, long-term residence, access to nationality and anti-discrimination”....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Canadian Labor industry

This essay describes the canadian labor industry in the early and late 1900's and, how they affected the equal participation of women in the provision of labor services....  It will be guided by the following research questions: What were the stereotypes associated with women in the canadian labor market and how did these influence allocation of duties as well as remuneration?... he essence of gender stereotyping in the canadian labor market in the early and the late 1900's can be traced back as early as 1660's....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Impact of Undocumented Immigration on Canadian Economy and Labor Market

nbsp; Undocumented immigrants in Canada are defined as people who take part in the canadian labor force by illegally crossing the borders and not taking into consideration the expiry of their visa or overstaying their visas (Milkman, 2012).... "Impact of Undocumented Immigration on Canadian Economy and labor Market" paper explores the concept of illegal immigration in Canada.... Although illegal immigration has a huge international relevance, it has not been exhaustively studied in Canada, especially with regard to its impact on the economy and market labor....
11 Pages (2750 words) Research Paper

The History of Chinese Head Tax

This coursework "The history of Chinese Head Tax" focuses on the Canadian government that is at the forefront of the fight against discrimination against the immigrants.... Immediately the canadian Pacific Railway was completely constructed and operating, the federal government acted fast and put a restriction on the Chinese migration to Canada....
9 Pages (2250 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us