StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Explaining how each of the following situations would be resolved by the courts - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
[Instructor Name] Case Solutions 1. The action taken by animal rights group is a fully-protected action and the court of law may intervene into this matter only if there are compelling reasons to do it or there is a chance of anarchy that will spread out due to the open expression committed by the animal rights group…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
Explaining how each of the following situations would be resolved by the courts
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Explaining how each of the following situations would be resolved by the courts"

Case Solutions The action taken by animal rights group is a fully-protected action and the court of law may intervene into this matter only if there are compelling reasons to do it or there is a chance of anarchy that will spread out due to the open expression committed by the animal rights group. The Time, Place and Manner doctrine of the court would compel the court of law to take reasonable action against the animal rights group but another doctrine of the court, i.e. Public Forum” would encourage the court to take no harsh actions.

This is because Public Forum doctrine provides a levy to the animal rights group as they organized their protest on sidewalks and in the parks (McClory). 2. No, the news director is not right because the reporter and news team has not heard the opinion of Assistant Principal Johnson on student’s claim. Since the news team has decided to go on-air with the report, there are chances that either the students or the news team is committing would be seen by the Assistant Principal as slander and thus implying that the speech is partially protected.

These types of scenarios are considered to be coming under the heavy regulations by the official authorities as this would damage the reputation of the Assistant Principal and he might file a case against the reporter and the News Director. Moreover, the newspaper has the liability that it communicates correct information and news to the audience without biasness and investigating the whole scenario. The on-airing of the report in prime time show would violate the basic rules of journalism, i.e. to communicate at neutral place and manner so that no one is hurt by the news or the person who is convicted is not humiliated, unless there are solid evidences to prove claims. 3. The care of duty requires a professional to fulfill his professional duties at best and do not present lame excuses for the mistakes he or she makes while performing the duty.

In the current scenario, the reporter is punishable by the court as he published the story without even asking Judge Jameson about his opinion or listening to his side of story. It was the duty of the newspaper in general and reporter in particular to complete their investigation of the matter before publishing the story in the newspaper. This act of the newspaper is a slander which would require government or the court to intervene and interrogate the reporter why did he publish the story without investigating the whole matter.

Moreover, the Judge would be righteous to question the commitment of the reporter with his or her profession and might put charges of damaging his personal reputation. In this scenario, the reporter will have to compensate financially or morally by asking for public excuse to the judge. Even if he has solid proof against the Judge that he is involved in drug trafficking and child abuse, the reporter should have completed the investigations first. 4. Pica should tell her publisher that she will not replace her ace reporter Ivanna Noe or take her out of the investigation.

This is because this act of Pica might de-motivate the reporter or the reporter might hit back on Pica by saying that she actually violated the workplace ethics or the employment contract. If the mayor thinks that the reporter might neutralize the investigation report according to her perception, that he should approach Pica and ask her to follow on the investigation on her own and see if there are unproven or dishonest content going to be published in the investigation report. Another argument that Pica might use in order to support her reporter’s reputation and her involvement in the series is that the if she stops Noe from participating into the series investigation under the pressure of a Government figure, this would be seen as the violation of Freedom of Press.

It should b the utmost priority of the journalists that they remain neutral in investigative reports and does not take particular sides or favor any party. Pica should tell her publisher that when the report will be published, the conclusion would be provided keeping in view the facts and figures. Then if the mayor thinks that his personal reputation is being damaged on the basis of weak evidences, he is welcomed to challenge the report and take Pica and Noe to the court of law for resolution.

Work Cited McClory, Toni. "The Free Speech Clause." 09 June 2006. breitlinks.com. 16 September 2013 .

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Explaining how each of the following situations would be resolved by Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1485935-explaining-how-each-of-the-following-situations
(Explaining How Each of the Following Situations Would Be Resolved by Essay)
https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1485935-explaining-how-each-of-the-following-situations.
“Explaining How Each of the Following Situations Would Be Resolved by Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/journalism-communication/1485935-explaining-how-each-of-the-following-situations.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Explaining how each of the following situations would be resolved by the courts

Highschool and American Government

In certain situations, individuals or corporate giants may require new laws that would safeguard their interests.... This essay stresses that  legislators take several factors into account, before casting their vote in Congress.... There are an array of issues and policies that influence the decision making of legislators....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The Context of Employee Relations against a Changing Background

On the other hand, a different way of looking at organizations is to view them as pluralities of interest groups, each with differing and occasionally opposing interests, which might come together in alliances, although these alliances shift and modify according to the situations.... In this way, authority and control takes place in a number of areas of the organization and loyalty is commanded by the leaders of the groups, which are frequently in competition with each other for resources....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

The Frye Standard and the Daubert Standard

579 (1993) cases touched on the courts view of science as the issues surrounding both cases were on the basis of scientific evidence.... As a substitute to this standard, many law courts apply Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, as the basis for professional testimony and scientific evidence.... In my essay I will provide an explanation of how courts view science and how that view has changed over the last century.... ?? Problems have come up with this standard, due to the fact that it has led to eyebrows being raised regarding the vitality of the standard and on its flexibility to be able to adjust to different situations and fresh and new scientific matters, where "general" or "widespread" approval is not gathered....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper

MEDIATION between Saudi Arabia and The U.S

The process includes conflict resolution procedures and mechanisms, which allows the conflicting parties to reach an agreement that would not result in litigation.... A current review of the global legal and business scenarios reveal that increasingly larger numbers of conflict resolution is taking place through arbitration, mediation and negotiation....
35 Pages (8750 words) Thesis

Crimsons Motion for Judgment

nbsp;Cameron Frye would be within the policy definition of occupying the car, although he is outside of the vehicle, so long as (a) he is within the geographical distance of sixteen feet from the car and (2) there was a reasonable relationship to the vehicle at the time.... courts also require that deliberate intent be established before recovery will be precluded under the public policy for deliberate infliction of injury.... But once the ride was over, Cameron was concerned that his father would notice that the mileage on the car had increased....
19 Pages (4750 words) Case Study

Sex Discrimination and the Spirit of Section 15 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms

Since its inception, social and political changes have challenged fundamental notions of gender equality so that the courts have faced significant challenges in striking the correct balance and ensuring that eradicating gender differences are consistent with public policy and changing social and political trends and traditions.... This essay explores how the Canadian courts have made this distinction and attempted to strike a fair balance between the two concepts in their interpretation and application of the spirit of Section 15 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

To What Extent Does Dworkin's Account of Judicial Disagreement Threaten the Plain Fact View of Law

hellip; According to the positivist theorists, this would be the end of the inquiry.... nbsp; It stands to reason that, if laws were clear and “bright-line,” then there would be no need for appellate courts or the Supreme Court; there would be no dissenting opinions; no concurring opinions that come to the same result as the majority, just on different grounds; indeed, little reason for judges at all.... nbsp; Legal conflicts would be minimal....
14 Pages (3500 words) Term Paper

Integration through Jurisprudence - The Role of Courts

The paper "Integration through Jurisprudence - The Role of courts" highlights that the issue of economic integration through jurisprudence is a fundamental issue with courts plays crucial role matching with that of legislators of giving clear and comprehensive explanations of the laws.... nbsp;… Compared to the civil law of legal system, countries those who have common law would have the capacity of providing better protections for their investors and have more developed financial markets....
24 Pages (6000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us