StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Ethical Issues in Privatization of Jails - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Running Head: Privatization Ethical Issues in the Privatization of Jails (Name) (Subject) (Instructor) (Date) Abstract Florida Governor Rick Scott recently incurred the ire of various groups for his push to privatize nearly thirty prisons in Florida. Arguing that such a move to privatize state prisons will save the state crucial funds, the decision nevertheless incited negative reactions, a good bulk of which emphasizes Scott’s alliance with private prison companies…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
Ethical Issues in Privatization of Jails
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Ethical Issues in Privatization of Jails"

Download file to see previous pages

The idea of privatizing prisons may not have been the brainchild of Florida Governor Rick Scott, but the implementation of the said move is certainly connected recently with him. The primary argument for the action is to save the state some $22 million annually (Deslatte, 2011). Critics claim that the perceived benefit does not warrant ovelooking the negative consequences. Furthermore, accusations are being levelled against Scott for allegedly having a conflict of interests in the matter. What follows is an examination of the moral grounds from which both sides may derive the strength of their respective arguments.

The Moral Value of Privatizing Prisons One pertinent question that ought to be asked is, “What moral principle could serve as the basis for the privatization of prisons?” One principle could be the moral responsibility of the citizens of the state to contribute to the preservation of the state. If the latter entails saving the state’s funds, then this could provide a strong foundation for the argument. Considering that Governor Scott is not just any ordinary citizen but an official of the state, then he has a moral obligation to protect the state’s interests.

More importantly, Kantian ethics dictates that an individual is bound by duty to fulfill a moral obligation, because the latter is inherently right (Albert, Denise, and Peterfreund, 1980). In other words, if the state can be preserved through the intelligent management of funds, then actions contributing to such a consequence can be morally justified. More importantly, regardless of consequences, Governor Scott was merely acting out of a sense of duty, as far as Immanuel Kant is concerned. Not only can such a position be argued for by appealing to a higher moral principle, but it can be demonstrated that privatizing jails can lead to beneficial consequences.

One of the perceived beneficial consequences was mentioned above, namely, that the state may be able to save funds, and consequently, sustain itself. Another good consequence is the possibility of such prisons to actually improve their operating conditions. Often, this is the case when a state institution is privatized, since the funding is now allocated primarily for the improvement of the involved institution, without having to go through a tedious process of bidding just to acquire a larger share of funding.

In other words, the private funds may thus be utilized for the sole purpose of improving the prisons. This will invariably lead to better reform facilities and programs, larger capacities, and a generally improved level of security for the state. It must be acknowledged that such improvements will unnecessarily cost the state a good deal of money, unnecessary since it can be shouldered by private institutions. The Ethical Challenges Posed by a Corporatist Penal Framework As with examining the possible moral grounds of privatizing prisons, the opposite argument ought to be analyzed on the basis of moral grounds.

First, it must be noted that in privatizing a state-run institution, an implied message is being delivered, namely, that the

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ethical Issues in Privatization of Jails Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1431421-privitalizing-jails
(Ethical Issues in Privatization of Jails Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1431421-privitalizing-jails.
“Ethical Issues in Privatization of Jails Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1431421-privitalizing-jails.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Ethical Issues in Privatization of Jails

Are Private Entrepreneurs of Punishment More Efficient than Government Ones

The privatization of the correction and punishment facilities has been a growing trend in the UK for the last few years.... In short, privatization of punishment can take the form of outsourcing, build-operate-transfer services and market testing.... Private Entrepreneurs of Punishment Are More Efficient and More Effective Than Government Agencies privatization is the word used to describe the “systematic transfer of government functions and programs into the private sector” (Ashworth, 2005)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Ethical Discussion of the Private Prison Industry

hellip; With more than 50 companies operating within the federal and state criminal justice system, the privatization of incarceration has become a five billion dollar business.... million prisoners were locked up in local county jails and in state and federal prisons (Fisher 1).... Name Date Professor's Section/# An ethical Discussion of the Private Prison Industry The United States has more incarcerated people than any other country in the world ?...
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Governments Should Not Run Businesses

It is said that "In a world of instrumental rationality institutions are unnecessary; ideas and ideologies don't matter; and efficient markets--both economic and political--characterize economies.... - (Douglass C.... North pp 1) The Economic History of the World has traversed through various policies and schools of thought in different periods....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Case against the Privatization of Prisons

The globalization of the world economy and the opening up of the markets has given a new thrust to the demand for the privatization of the state run facilities.... The governments and the state financial institutions also seem to be more then willing to comply with such expectations and the privatization of the social and the state institutions is considered to be a panacea for all economic ills.... Besides the privatization of the public institutions leaves the governments less burdened, thus leaving them with ample time and resources at their disposal, to take care of more pressing responsibilities and obligations....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Discussion Board creminal justice

(Burright) Nonetheless, in recent past the privatization of prisons and jails found the way back into the criminal justice, once again arousing a wave of controversy and debate.... Over-crowded correctional facilities, decreasing revenues, increasing crime rates, public call for more prison sentences and longer criminals' incarceration are among the factors that forced the nation's prison system to once again consider the option of private contracting to provide privatization of prisons and jails....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Naomi Klein's Don't Fence Us in

hellip; It is evidently clear from the discussion that the issue of how capitalism erect barriers that keep out parts of society from enjoying their rights to exercise their freedom and to partake in their share of resources such as water, electricity, and education has been tied to policies such as privatization.... Naomi Klein's "Don't Fence Us in" The issue of how capitalism erect barriers that keep out parts of society from enjoying their rights to exercise their freedom and to partake in their share of resources such as water, electricity and education has been tied to policies such as privatization....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Ethical Issues in Access To Water - Is Water a Human Right

This paper "ethical issues in Access To Water - Is Water a Human Right?... In this reference, the ethical issues related to the bottled water industry is mentioned.... nbsp; Various issues like cultural traditions, local practices, and different societal values are the determinants of the water management process and are very useful in the structuring of water ethics.... There are other issues, which centres the notion of water management and often they are not perceivable by the human senses....
19 Pages (4750 words) Essay

The Cause of the Problems at USPS

Having been tasked to look into the issues affecting the government-owned institution, Herr termed the While many factors could be blamed for the situation, this paper has zeroed in on one issue: the business model.... Besides highlighting these issues, the paper has offered the best model to adopt, and lucidly elaborated what entails.... In light of these issues, this paper seeks to investigate the real cause of the problems at USPS.... Further, a prognosis will be offered upon identifying the major issues bedevilling the USPS....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us