StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Principles of the Law of Negligence - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In this study, a particular case regarding Principles of the Law of Negligence will be deeply analyzed, discussing different aspects of the case. The Donoghue v Stevenson case is one of the most important cases as it set precedents that have been used in negligence law…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful
Principles of the Law of Negligence
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Principles of the Law of Negligence"

Principles of the Law of Negligence (Donoghue v Stevenson) The Donoghue v Stevenson case is one of themost important cases as it set precedents that have been used in negligence law. The case involves the plaintiff, Donoghue, who on 26th August 1928, went to a restaurant with a friend, who embarked on purchasing ginger beer, which was packed in a sealed opaque bottle. Thereafter, Donoghue drank the contents of the bottle before her friend poured the rest of the contents of the ginger bottle beer into a tumbler. Upon pouring the contents, they discovered a decomposing snail pouring out of the bottle. Donoghue was very shocked by the sight of the snail and the resultant impurities poured from the bottle. In addition she suffered from severe stomach pains (gastro enteritis) which she related to the contents of the ginger beer bottle (manufactured by Stevenson), which she had consumed earlier on (Enright 347). The plaintiff argued that the defendant’s negligence (snail infested beer) caused her grievous emotional harm (shock) and extreme gastroenteritis. In her argument, she argued that the manufacturer was liable because he had manufactured beer that was meant for the consumption by the general public and which led to her illness. In fact, the bottle was labelled under his name, thus proving ownership of the beer and its contents. In addition, the beer was sealed before consumption meaning that the contents of the bottle (ginger beer and the snail) could be traced directly to Stevenson. Therefore, the defendant had a duty of care to Donoghue because she was directly harmed by his actions and the defendant should have had a check mechanism in place to ensure that the ginger beer was safe for public consumption. Since Stevenson failed to do this, he was liable for negligence. The plaintiff was unsuccessful in trial but her case was appealed in the House of Lords where it was ruled in her favor on grounds of the neighbor principle. In his judgement, Lord Atkins asserted that one should take reasonable care to ensure that one’s actions do not harm their neighbor. In short, one should not intentionally harm their neighbor in foresight, as they will be found to be negligent for any grievous harm inflicted on their neighbors due to their actions/ omissions. In this case, neighbors refer to people who are foreseeably affected in reasonable degree by a person’s omissions or actions. This means that a duty of care is owed to one’s neighbors but not to the world in general. This principle is a legal application of the love your neighbor philosophy (Linden 335). The other major point of the neighbor principle to consider is the consideration of one’s action or inaction and its direct effect on a neighbor. If one’s actions/inactions are deemed to have reasonably been responsible for the affliction affecting another person (neighbor), then the person held responsible for the inaction or action will be held responsible as they owe a duty of care in the eyes of the law. Therefore, one should be very keen and vigilant when pursuing actions that may cause injury to a neighbor. With relation to the Donoghue v Stevenson case, it’s clear that the defendant was negligent because the manufacturer put beer in the bottle with the specific intention of having it consumed by the consumer, Donoghue (Linden 340). Some of the issues raised in the case is whether a duty of care is owed between people with no prior contact such as between Donoghue and Stevenson. The House of Lords tackled this issue by stating that even in the absence of prior contact, a duty of care is owed because the actions/omissions of Stevenson led to grievous harm on the plaintiff Donoghue. In addition, there were actions that if the defendant had undertaken, the plaintiff would not have suffered. In this case, had Stevenson instituted a quality assurance system, before sealing the bottle of ginger beer, the impurities would not have been present in the ginger beer bottle. Also, the manufacturer’s actions wouldn’t have resulted in Donoghue’s shock and contraction of gastro-enteritis. In addition, by having sealed the opaque bottle, the plaintiff was unable to see the contents of the bottle. Therefore, the actions of the defendant left the plaintiff with no option but to trust that the contents of the beer were safe and he depended on the manufacturer. This points to a relationship where a duty of care is existent. When a duty of care is existent, negligence on the part of one party resulting in injury and loss should result to legal remedy on the injured party. In the Donoghue v Stevenson case, the plaintiff was affected by the negligence of the defendant as he provided a flawed commodity. In such a case, the consumer is supposed to have legal recourse against the producer/manufacturer, as denying this remedy is a social injustice. Therefore, Donoghue was right to sue Stevenson for damages (Enright 353). In conclusion, the manufacturer’s inaction (negligence) was responsible for the plaintiff’s injury and therefore a duty of care was owed. Indeed, manufactures have a duty of care to the consumers of their goods especially when the products are not inspected between production and consumption. Therefore, for a consumer to sue the manufacturer, the presence of prior contact or a contractual relationship is not necessary. This decision by the House of Lords resulted in the formation of the neighbor principle, which is deemed to a large extent as the foundation of the law of negligence in its current form and application. Works Cited. Enright, Christopher. Legal Technique. Annandale, N.S.W.: Federation, 2002. Print. Linden, Allen, and Feldthusen, Bruce. Canadian Tort Law. [10th ed.]. Canada: Lex Nexis., 2015. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Principles of the Law of Negligence Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Principles of the Law of Negligence Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1701164-principles-of-the-law-of-negligence
(Principles of the Law of Negligence Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Principles of the Law of Negligence Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/law/1701164-principles-of-the-law-of-negligence.
“Principles of the Law of Negligence Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1701164-principles-of-the-law-of-negligence.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Principles of the Law of Negligence

Provisional Assessment of Law Investigation

Basically, tort law commonly refers to a civil wrong not arising from a contract and in the case of negligence, everyone has a duty of care owed to the neighbour (Capiro Industries vs.... According to Terry & Giugni (2009), there are four elements of the tort of negligence that have to be proved by the plaintiff and these include the following: there is need to prove that the defendant owed the plaintiff a duty of care, the defendant breached that duty by falling below expected standards, the defendant's conduct caused the plaintiff to suffer physical or economic harm (causation) and the harm suffered by the plaintiff was reasonably foreseeable (remoteness)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Mens Rea for Murder

Criminal law 26 May 2015 MENS REA FOR MURDER AND FAULT ELEMENT FOR INVOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER There has been an on-going debate as to the evidence of guilt or the degree of culpability that is required in order to convict a criminal for the crime of murder and involuntary manslaughter.... However, it is a fact in criminal law, that the “criminal intent” or the “mens rea” of the offender to be convicted for the commission of any of the crimes under the Code requires a different degree of culpability which is dependent on the nature of the crime....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Understand and Apply the Principles of Liability in Negligence a Business Context

Generally, vicarious liability operates within the law of torts.... Mainly, it has created five main scenarios as demonstrated in the chart below: Always directly liable; always vicariously liable; may be vicariously liable; not vicariously liable; and is always vicariously liable Vicarious Liability Under the tort of negligence, employers are vicariously liable for the torts committed by their employees in the course of employment.... Understand and apply the principles of liability in negligence a business context A business at a given time is bound to be liable for some acts either it has committed or has been committed by any third party who had the ability, right or duty to control the activities of the business....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

How a Failure to Take Action May Result in a Claim of Negligence

The key function of the law of Torts is to offer remedies to those claimants who have suffered loss, infringements of rights or harm, which may include physical injury to property or persons, damage to financial interests and reputations of persons, and interference with a person's enjoyment and use of their property such as land.... This is because; the law of Tort requires that a claimant must be able to show that the tort caused them a loss and that the person who is committing the tort owed them a duty of care2....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Legal Foundation for Business

hellip; The second section will involve an analysis of the case in relation to its contribution to the development of the law of negligence in British and Commonwealth Law.... The House of Lords, being the highest adjudicating body with some law making powers at that time had to decide on how to deal with the problem....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Lord Atkins Speech in Donoghue v Stevenson

hellip; However there have been policy grounds which have been used as a basis of decision by the courts. The structure of negligence is based on flexibility, but as it has been seen that the evolution of the tort was not quite favoured by the courts and so in recent years there have been restrictions placed on its scope. 1The decision of Donoghue v.... he focus therefore in claims of negligence is that a duty has to be established for any claims for possible liability....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Negligence in English Law

This paper outlines different cases and examples of negligence in English law and factors caused them.... There have been several cases, where the courts have ruled that the duty of care, inherent in psychiatric injury that was caused on account of negligence, was present due to policy considerations (Victim of self – inflicted injuries owes no duty of care, 2000).... The author of this essay "negligence in English Law" describes English Law on defenses to a claim in negligence....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

All Possible Negligence Claims in the Business Law

nbsp;… The final case that has to be considered is Osman which took the law of negligence to the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) in respect to the duty of care and the immunity of police officers from liability under Hill.... This paper 'All Possible Negligence Claims in the Business Law" focuses on the fact that the elements of negligence are the duty of care; breach of that duty of care; causation, i.... nbsp; There are two branches of duty of care, those duties recognised by law and those inferred by the circumstances....
10 Pages (2500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us