StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Gumtree Offering a Second Hand iPhone 6 - Law of Contract - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Gumtree Offering a Second Hand iPhone 6 - Law of Contract " is a great example of a law case study. Bob sees an online advertisement on Gumtree offering a second hand iPhone 6 for sale at £300. The advert contains Cecil’s name as the seller together with his address. Bob sees this as an ideal replacement for his ageing iPhone 4 and hence he visits the seller after work…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Gumtree Offering a Second Hand iPhone 6 - Law of Contract"

1. Facts Bob sees an online advertisement on Gumtree offering a second hand iPhone 6 for sale at £300. The advert contains Cecil’s name as the seller together with his address. Bob sees this as an ideal replacement for his aging iPhone 4 and hence he visits the seller after work. He gives £300 to Cecil for the iPhone. Cecil doesn’t want to sell the phone to Bob since he has already accepted a $350 offer for the iPhone from his mother. Issue The issue is whether the online advert by Cecil constitutes a valid offer and thus if he is bound by it to sell the iPhone to Bob. Rule The law of contract states that an offer is an indication (expression) of willingness to enter into a contract on the precise terms with no other negotiation such that a binding contract can be formed only with acceptance. It may be made expressly or impliedly by the offeror on the precise terms with an assurance to be bound by it if the offeree accepts the offer. Whether a valid offer has been made is determined using the subjective test as held in Smith v. Hughes1 case depending on how reasonable person would view the particular situation. An offer is to be distinguished from an invitation to treat which is an indication of one’s willingness to negotiate a contract as was held in Harvey v Facey2. Advertisements are generally considered invitations to treat on the basis of the party’s intentions as held in Partridge v Crittenden3 as the one who advertised could not have intended to be bound to sell to everyone who would accept unless it is advertised to a specific Peron or for instance if the advert stated that the item would be sold only to the first person accepting. Analysis The advert that Bob sees is placed on an online platform. It is expected that many people (Bob included) accessing the online platform would be able to see the advert and if interested make an offer to Cecil to buy the iPhone whether at the same price or at a different price. In other words, the advert is intended to draw people’s attention that Cecil is selling the iPhone and at how much he would be willing to sell it so that people can make offers for purchase and if Cecil accepts, a contract of sale is put in place. This is an invitation to treat since a reasonable person would not expect that the advert is an offer made to him unless it is specifically addressed to him. As such it is reasonable to treat the advert an invitation to treat rather than an offer. Conclusion Based on the facts of the case, relevant laws and decided cases, it would be reasonable to treat Cecil’s advert as an invitation to treat as opposed to an offer. Cecil is therefore not bound to sell the phone to anyone but only to the one who makes an offer to him and he accepts the offer. In this case, he has already accepted his mother’s offer and is therefore not bound to sell the phone to Bob as he has not accepted his offer. 2. Facts Les offers to sell his four year old Jaguar X-type motor car for £8,000 to Dvina his former wife on 21st September stating that a notice in writing is required. Davina sends a letter to less on 22nd September accepting his offer but the letter does not arrive until 29 September. On 28th September, Les having not heard from Davina sells the car to Rex, his civil partner for £8,500. Issue The issue is whether a valid offer existed between the two parties and whether the letter by Davina to Less constituted a valid acceptance and hence whether Davina can sue Les for breach of contract for failing to sell the car to her. Rule The law of contract states that an offer is an indication (expression) of willingness to enter into a contract on the precise terms with no other negotiation such that a binding contract can be formed only with acceptance. It may be made expressly or impliedly by the offeror on the precise terms with an assurance to be bound by it if the offeree accepts the offer. On the other hand, acceptance is an indication by the offeree of readiness to be bound by the terms and conditions of the offer. In Powell v Lee (1908) it was held that acceptance has to be communicated by the person to whom it is made4. An offer must not include a clause of acceptance by silence as was held in Felthouse v Bindley. Where an offer has specified a method of acceptance say by post, acceptance has to be through that means as was held in Co. Ltd v R. J. Pulleyn & Sons (York) ltd (1975)5. Where acceptance is through post, the contract will come into being the very moment the acceptance letter is posted as was held in Adams v. Lindsell (1818)6. The post rule applies when the parties either expressly or impliedly contemplated post as the means of acceptance. Analysis Les communicates his offer to sell the car specifically to Davina his former wife at £8,000 on 21st September. He goes ahead to specify that Davina is to communicate acceptance through writing (post). Davina accepts Les offer and as a result writes a letter of acceptance to Les and posts it on 22nd September. Not that post in this case is the contemplated means of communicating offer since Les has stated that he is to be notified in writing. Thus, according to the Post rule, Davina communicates acceptance on this day despite the fact that the acceptance letter delays at the post office and only arrives on 29th. Unfortunately by the time it arrives, Les has already sold the car. Conclusion Based on the relevant law, cases and the analysis above, Les makes a valid offer to Davina. The fact that it is in writing and is specific as to Car type, selling price and means of acceptance makes it valid and indicates willingness to be bound. According to the post rule, acceptance is also valid since it is done through post as specified by Les and is communicated by Davina the offeror. Based on post rule, acceptance happens on 22nd September when the letter is posted and hence by the time Les is selling the car to another party, a contract of sale already exists between him and Davina. As such, he is bound to sell the car to Davina and not to any other party since the offer was specifically addressed to her. As such, Davina could sue Les for damages since he has breached the contract between them. 3. Meaning of the terms ‘counter offer’ and ‘battle of forms’ In explaining the meaning of the above terms, it is worth noting that a contract is only formed when an offer made by one party is accepted by the other contacting party. Others requirements for a valid contract include intention to create a contract and consideration. However, it should be noted that the party that accepts the offer must do so unequivocally. Where the other party fails to accept the other’s offer unequivocally, this gives rise to a counter offer. In other words, a counter offer arises when the accepting party seeks to vary the standard terms of the offer or puts forwards its own terms and hence does not accept the offer unequivocally. This is deemed an implied rejection of the original party’s offer. Situations arise when the two contracting parties in their attempt to incorporate their own standard terms often throw into question which terms govern the contract and whether a contract exists at all. This is called battle of the forms. Battle of the forms occur unwittingly and only when a dispute arises and the contracting parties seek to rely upon a particular contractual term that the issue of which of the different sets of terms are operative comes into question hence giving rise to the battle of forms. It can thus be concluded that a counter offer will lead to the battle of forms. The terms’ counter offer’ and ‘battle of forms’ can be illustrated by court cases. Such cases include the decision in Butler Machine Tool v Ex-Cell-O Corporation (1977)7 where parties were involved in the battle of forms as to which terms guided the contract. It was argued that in such a situation, it has to be established whether a contract existed in the first place and secondly which terms apply to the contract. In this regard, it was determined that the binding terms will be found by looking for a point where one party gives the other the impression that they have agreed to the other party’s terms. In this case, it happened when the suppliers sent back a signed tear off slip from the buyer implying that by signing the slip, the parties would be bound by the buyer’s terms. In this case, the last party that puts forward their standard terms that are not explicitly rejected by the recipient wins the battle though this is not always the case. In Tekdata interconnections Ltd v Amphenol (2009)8, the seller acknowledged the buyer’s terms but included its own terms in the note before delivering the goods (counter offer). On accepting the goods delivered by the seller, it was deemed to have accepted the seller’s standard terms since it did not challenge the terms on accepting the order. Thus, though the battle of forms arose as to which terms were applicable to the contract, the decision confirmed that the offer and acceptance analysis has to be applied to battle of forms situations. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Gumtree Offering a Second Hand iPhone 6 - Law of Contract Case Study, n.d.)
Gumtree Offering a Second Hand iPhone 6 - Law of Contract Case Study. https://studentshare.org/law/2085301-courswork
(Gumtree Offering a Second Hand IPhone 6 - Law of Contract Case Study)
Gumtree Offering a Second Hand IPhone 6 - Law of Contract Case Study. https://studentshare.org/law/2085301-courswork.
“Gumtree Offering a Second Hand IPhone 6 - Law of Contract Case Study”. https://studentshare.org/law/2085301-courswork.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Gumtree Offering a Second Hand iPhone 6 - Law of Contract

Law of Contract and Terms of Contracts

The writer of the paper "law of contract" detailed discusses the different aspects of the conclusion of a contract.... A contract is an agreement between two parties in which each party exchanges consideration in return for consideration from the other party.... When the offer is accepted and there is a consensus, a contract is established.... The consensus of a contract is based on the terms of the offer and acceptance of the consideration....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The History of Blackberry Phones

Blackberry outperform iphone in features and users Abstract BlackBerry is a Smartphone device developed and designed by Canadian company Research In Motion (RIM) in 1999.... On the other hand, iphone is the first touch screen mobile phone device developed by Apple Company during the initial period of 2000.... Blackberry and iphone are currently engaged in fierce battle for supremacy in global markets.... Both blackberry and iphone have their own advantages and disadvantages....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Proposal

Lord Melbray v the Backstreet Boyos and Basils Bistro

The provisions of the law of contract requires that the parties involved must agree on the contractual terms, through a meeting of the minds, without any party giving a diversionary view regarding the contractual terms, which would amount to a counter offer2.... Name: Course: Date: contract law Introduction The case Lord Melbray v the Backstreet Boyos and Basil's Bistro requires a full legal analysis, before a conclusion is reached, and therefore an advice issued to the aggrieved parties....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Law of Contract

The paper entitled 'The law of contract' presents a man who has been led to expect shall come to pass and that what has been promised to him shall be performed.... In simple words, the law of contract determines the rights and obligations to be made and executed.... 'A contract is an agreement enforceable at law made between two or more persons, by which rights are acquired by one or more to acts or forbearance on the part of the other or others....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Apple iPhone

Additionally, the Apple Corporation has become one of the main players in the global consumer electronics industry (such as iphone, iPod etc).... e, modern and useful technology products; it has released another gadget that has been carried on to be a big hit, “Apple iphone”, which is one of big hits of the Apple Corporation since, this technology based product has brought revolution in the global mobile and PDAs This paper presents a detailed analysis of the Apple iphone and its technology overview....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

The Concept of iPhone 6

The major differences that the iphone 6 has with the preceding iPhones are that it.... he reality is that no one truly knows when the iphone 6 is turning out (Boxall para4) Everybody has a As such, Apple discharges an item when it's great and complete (Boxall para2) ... It is said because the iphone 6 is to a great extent a complimentary item to the iPhone 5S, giving individuals a decision of screen sizes, the debates I going on in the market place that Apple will be releasing another model of smartphone shortly (Lutlow para4)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Research Paper

Contrasting of iPhone 6 and Galaxy S5

The paper "Contrasting of iphone 6 and Galaxy S5" describes that Galaxy's customized screens have an impact on improving the market share of the company.... Perhaps the introduction of the iphone 6 will provide features that might be economical.... In relation to iphone 6 and Samsung Galaxy S5, various marketing strategies set the products on the market.... iphone 6 in the marketing strategy concentrates on the introduction of a 5....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Designing for IPhone 6

In the paper 'Designing for iphone 6' the author discusses the latest brand in the iPhone phone series.... In other words, an iphone 6 is just a computer that doubles as a phone all in one.... An iphone 6 also has an inbuilt tracker device system that allows the owner to track its whereabouts in case it gets stolen or lost.... Overall, iphone 6's build quality is excellent in that the buttons and switches are uniquely and effectively designed since they are firm, responsive to touch and ring tone produced is pleasing to the ear....
7 Pages (1750 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us