StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

An issue affecting two or more countries - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name: Course: Professor: Date: Source analysis of an issue affecting two or more countries After the tricky proxy war against the Soviets on the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, US and Pakistani support of the mujahideen set a precedent for the later growth of Taliban…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.6% of users find it useful
An issue affecting two or more countries
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "An issue affecting two or more countries"

Download file to see previous pages

While CIA provided information from the satellites about abandoned soviet trucks and weapon depots for the Taliban, ISI transferred the information to the men on ground (Coll p. 291) making it possible for the Taliban to conquer Afghanistan with astonishing speed uniting the country for the benefit of Pakistan, United States and Saudi Arabia (Reeve p. 191). After the September 11 attacks, US invaded the Taliban controlled Afghanistan asking all countries to cut off Taliban support. Pakistan ordered the Taliban embassy to be closed in 2001, allied with the US and supported the invasion by providing its forward military bases.

The hard war in Afghanistan followed up by a bloody insurgency caused US to lose unprecedented amount of war founds trying to control Afghan territory. Adding to the troubles were lack of understanding of terrain and psyche of the local people. The overwhelming force and technology, while allowed the US to have complete air superiority and highly reinforced military bases in the region, could still not help them achieve actual victory and control over the territory outside their bases. The insurgency caused alot of contention between USA and Pakistan as allies and the US still ended up blaming Pakistan for supporting Afghan Taliban after calling it their top non-NATO ally.

This paper compares and contrasts BBC reports and The Washington Post with respect to the US allegations and Pakistani denials. BBC reports Pakistan being accused of playing a double game by the US (Collyns). After interviewing a few prisoners, according to BBC, the US officials concluded that Pakistan was actively supporting Taliban insurgency in Afghanistan for a hidden agenda. This can be seen as a fallacy of composition created from a single point of view being viewed as the resulting aim of country’s net actions.

Pakistani ISI has been a powerful element both in the country and in its defense against the enemy powers when it came to proxy wars. The BBC uses the circumstantial prisoner witnesses to support the accusation by the US officials. While attributing repeated denials to Pakistan in two instances, the report suggests the US accusations overly weighed and further states them as a fact by presenting a BBC documentary to back up the accusations as facts. This strains the neutral point of view of the report which should be there in an international news article fully attributing views to their actual sources and not stating contentions opinions or conflicting truths as facts.

Furthermore, in addition to the US accusations, the BBC report itself alleges that Pakistan has helped and harboured Afghan Taliban in its territory stating it as a ‘plain to see’ fact (Collyns). The Washington Post, on the other hand, also attributes accusations to the US and denials to Pakistan but keeps it to that (Leiby). The report can be contrasted with that of BBC’s in a clear cut way. As a clear contrast to the BBC report, this report presents quotations of US accusations in text with conflicting quotations of Pakistani denials making it more balanced and neutral in its point of view.

The Washington Post report also uses the BBC report as a reference but puts it in a more neutral way without any presumptions. The BBC excerpts are quoted to tell the US side of the story while the Pakistani foreign minister is clearly attributed to have categorically put

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“An issue affecting two or more countries Article”, n.d.)
An issue affecting two or more countries Article. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1469173-an-issue-affecting-two-or-more-countries
(An Issue Affecting Two or More Countries Article)
An Issue Affecting Two or More Countries Article. https://studentshare.org/management/1469173-an-issue-affecting-two-or-more-countries.
“An Issue Affecting Two or More Countries Article”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1469173-an-issue-affecting-two-or-more-countries.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF An issue affecting two or more countries

Why is the European Crisis So Much More Severe than the US Crisis and What Could Be Done to Fix It

It is an issue which involves the management of economies in a currency zone, with their related economic and political issues arising from the fact that their citizens are doing... This crisis has caused difficulties for countries transacting with the euro making it difficult for countries involved to repay their government debts without gaining the help of third parties.... This crisis has caused difficulties for countries transacting with the euro making it difficult for countries involved to repay their government debts without gaining the help of third parties....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Internet Censorship: Laws Affecting the Internet

In some countries, there is little restriction while in others, the issue is handled with a lot of seriousness and governments have gone as far as limiting discussions amongst citizens and suppressing access of certain information.... INTERNET CENSORSHIP: LAWS affecting THE INTERNET Name: Institution: Abstract This paper seeks to look into the various aspects of internet censorship and the laws affecting the internet.... When looking at internet laws, there is the issue of intellectual property, which includes the rules on fair use and copyright, protection of digital media and circumvention of the same....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Groth issues of Aconex company

With each country having more than a billion consumers, both having strong presence in the IT and ITES sector and availability of quality services with cheaper labor, these two countries are the obvious choice for such a venture.... With each country having more than a billion consumers, both having strong presence in the IT and ITES sector and availability of quality services with cheaper labor, these two countries are the obvious choice for such a venture.... These two nations are the fastest growing economies today....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Water needs in Urban Countries

Issues related to water availability and shortages are evident globally.... ?Most of the outstanding problems pertaining to these issues are common among all regions such as climate change with other interregional issues such as internal political instability and inadequate… r management regulations also in play....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

US - Russian relations; how the embargo is affecting trade and the economy

As stated earlier, several countries and regions including the U.... Several countries including Albania, Canada, Moldovia, Australia, Switzerland and Montenegro followed suit6.... This paper will discuss how the recent US embargo on Russia is negatively affecting trade and the economy (in Russia), and how or if it may also affect a particular nation within the European Union....
4 Pages (1000 words) Outline

Cross-Cultural Issues Affecting HRM Strategies

nbsp;… Gender role expectations can also impact foreign HR models which should be used to make the business more efficient and close to local values and beliefs.... nbsp; Many of the HR models available which describe diversity would be usable in Saudi Arabia as it has been cited that workforce diversity is becoming a more important part of the value system in this country (Budhwar and Yaw, 2007, p.... This paper under the headline 'Cross-Cultural Issues affecting HRM Strategies" focuses on the fact that certain cross-cultural issues, such as how social groups view other social groups, can impact the question of how human resources efforts are coordinated....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

Marketing Issues Affecting Telecommunications Services

The globalization of telecommunication markets and the increasing integration of markets both domestically and internationally create pressures on regulation when it is not competitively neutral as between institutions within a national system and between countries (Palmer, 2008).... nbsp;  Secondly, the traditional specialist basis of the British telecommunication system has given way to a more conglomerate structure which has eroded the traditional distinctions between the major areas of telecom....
13 Pages (3250 words) Assignment

Ways of Providing for International Students in Melbourne

The author notes that such perceptions are based on the misguided view that international schools are most appropriate in underdeveloped countries whose local educational institutions and curriculum do not fit internationally mobile students.... Brown and Lauder have another perspective which alleges that international schools are one of the many platforms that developed countries have coined for partnership and mutual benefits and close to trade agreements.... He notes that the majority of the educated people in the world went through government-funded schools where more often than not, the government approves the curriculum....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us