StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Company law - gambotto pinciples - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The United States government passes a law making it illegal for American companies to purchase chemicals from a company that has French shareholders, and that action precipitates the company, AgChem pty Ltd, to expropriate minority shareholders shares (100 French shareholders) in order to do business with the U.S…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.1% of users find it useful
Company law - gambotto pinciples
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Company law - gambotto pinciples"

Problem Set 4, Question 10 Legal Issue The United s government passes a law making it illegal for American companies to purchase chemicals froma company that has French shareholders, and that action precipitates the company, AgChem pty Ltd, to expropriate minority shareholders shares (100 French shareholders) in order to do business with the U.S. Would this action violate the Gambotto Principles What steps must the company take for this to be legal under Australian lawThe Law A Mr. Gambotto, who was a minority shareholder in the company WPC Ltd, was not present when the majority shareholders voted to acquire minority shares in the company and was motivated to file a major law suit because he believed his rights were violated and his voice was not heard.

In regards to this case, Michael Yew Seong Chin in his article Being in the Minority: The CompulsoryAcquisition of Shares writes: The emancipation of the minority shareholders is a recent event. For most of the first century of company law they were virtually defenseless. In 1995, the High Court of Australia delivered a corporate law decision that led to a maelstrom of publicity and controversy. This was the Gambotto v WCP Ltd which significantly altered common law governing amendments to a company's articles of association.

Gambotto ushered in a new era of minority shareholder protections by significantly restricting the ability of the majority to acquire 100 percent ownership through amending the articles of association to introduce a new clause enabling the majority to compulsorily acquire shares of the minority. Gambotto introduces a new test for the validity of such amendments. (Heinonline 1)A new precedent had been set in corporate law.Application of Law to Facts In the original case trial Judge Mclelland J, injuncted the expropriation on the basis that majority shareholders were unjustly oppressing the minority shareholders.

That decision was reversed by the Court of Appeal. Here the court noted that the expropriated shareholders received fair compensation for their shares. Using a contraction approach, Priestly J pointed to the fact that the shareholders on becoming members, agreed to become bound by duly passed resolutions, and Meagher JA pointed out that there were enormous tax advantages for the corporation and compensation was fair (Whincop 11). Unhappy with the Priestly/Meagher decision, Gambotto went back to the Court of Appeal and a final decision was reached by Mchugh J: Mchugh determined that the business objective was proper since it enabled the company to save $4 million dollars in taxes.

Mchugh held that the concept of fairness had two basic aspects; fair dealing and fair price. In fair dealing one of the requirements is that full disclosure be made especially in regards to the purpose of and reasons for expropriation. He held that the majority had failed to prove that the expropriation was not oppressive as it had failed to make full disclosure of all material matters which might effect a members vote on the proposed modifications, and as such had dealt unfairly with minority shareholders.

(Whincop 13)ConclusionBefore AgChem can expropriate the minority shareholders shares, it will be required to:(a) have a meeting with all shareholders to disclose all materials as to why an expropriation must take place(b) the minority holders must be given a fair price and fair treatment If AgChem does the two items above (a&b) it will not violate the Gambotto Principles.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Company law - gambotto pinciples Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Company law - gambotto pinciples Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500702-company-law-gambotto-pinciples
(Company Law - Gambotto Pinciples Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
Company Law - Gambotto Pinciples Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500702-company-law-gambotto-pinciples.
“Company Law - Gambotto Pinciples Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1500702-company-law-gambotto-pinciples.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Company law - gambotto pinciples

Countrys Corporate Legal Framework Is a Reflection of Its Socio-Economic and Political Values

The amendment of the company executives' compensation clause in 1995 is a good example.... It is often said that a country's corporate legal framework is a reflection of its socio-economic and political values.... Corporate governance is a set of rules, processes and practices for controlling and directing corporations....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Company Law Reform Bill

While the Companies Bill 2006 introduces some new aspects to company law, it might have left the regulations of directors' duty up to judicial interpretation and company law.... 3 Under the provisions of the Companies Act 1985, together with principles of Common law and Equity, directors have a fiduciary relationship with the company they serve.... Romer J added that in the course of exercising his duties as a director, the director was subject to a certain standard in law....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Company Law - Articles of Association

Put another way, the principles of common law and equity effectively bind the majority share holders in the manifest exercise of their powers at the expense of minority shareholders.... It determines how company decisions will be made, what officers the company will have and how they will be elected.... In other words the Articles of the company constitute the… sis of a contract between the company and its members and it also binds the members to each other....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Minority Shareholders Proprietary Rights

The essay "Minority Shareholder's Proprietary Rights" focuses on the gambotto case which was the one that set the ball rolling when it came to minority shareholder rights.... hellip; The gambotto case in Australia was the one that set the ball rolling when it came to minority shareholder rights.... As in the case of gambotto in Australia, in a number of cases, the courts have taken cognizance to the fact that even if the plaintiff does not request for the two tests, the courts may and can subject the amendment to these tests and see to their fitment to the same....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Residual Duties of the Director in the Management

company law dictates that directors have a fiduciary relationship with the companies they serve.... As fiduciaries, directors are… They are: British courts have taken the position that the directors' duty of care is calculated to protect the company itself rather than the individual shareholders.... Section 309 of the Companies Act 1985 codified this criteria by dictating that directors owe a duty of care to act in the best interests of both the members and the employees of the company....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Taking Shareholder Rights Seriously

The issues connected with the shareholders are multifarious and are interconnected or interrelated to various stakeholders' interest in a business, and hence it becomes too difficult to enumerate the various situations which could be foreseen at the time of legislation or practicable to include in statutes, which warrants interpretations in the court of law for equitable justice to the parties concerned.... In the management of the company's affairs and decision making processes, it is generally perceived that the interest of the minority shareholders is not taken into consideration....
20 Pages (5000 words) Research Paper

Company Law: Incorporation of Companies

It is important to understand that the common law principle denotes that an individual who provides capital for a business operation, and is responsible for sharing the profits that the business makes, is also liable for any debts that the business under... This paper is an analysis on the notion that incorporation of companies has made it possible for individuals to have the ability of controlling companies, without them being liable for the liabilities of the company....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Company Law

The paper "company law" presents a discussion of the issues related to corporate and business law and activities such as raising and lowering of share capital, uses of loan capital, fixed charges and etc.... hellip; One of the fundamental advantages that would accrue for Green Books plc is the fact that in respect of share capital there has been strict control that has been placed by the Companies Act 2006 contrary to loan capital which has been controlled in a very minimal way by legislation and the majority of loan capital issue are decided upon the principles laid down in the contract or in other words by the mechanisms of contract law....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us