StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Descartes and Dreaming - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Renee Descartes was a philosopher that, although wasn't a follower of skepticism, held skeptic beliefs like any philosopher did. He stated that sense perception had a part in what a person claimed held the validity of truth, even though they could be misinterpreted…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.4% of users find it useful
Descartes and Dreaming
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Descartes and Dreaming"

Download file to see previous pages

What he was actually hinting at was the fact that although the concept of sensation could be utilized for different ideas, a difference could take place from other points of view on the object in discussion. In other words, states of being that were realized through the experience of sensation could in fact be found to be an actual illusion. Such as with dreaming. An individual might sense that they are awake and lucid but in actuality they are still dreaming, so, according to Descartes there is no factual way to prove when a person is awake and when they are dreaming, all the time.

However, Descartes admittedly pointed out that sense perception did hold value for some states of being. For example, if you are clothed and sitting at the table having a meal with your family, this can not be denied because your senses prove this is what you are doing. You can feel the morsels of food pass your lips, and go down as you swallow. In this regard, senses can be found to be a valid way of discovering the truth (Monarch Notes 1963). Descartes had the renowned ability to make a person question the truth in the most valid of concepts.

As with knowledge, he asked how a person could know for a certainty how the intelligence that they possessed could actually hold any truth How do you know for a certainty This can phase back into the idea of being asleep and dreaming and being in a state of wakefulness. Descartes would ask, "How do you really know" (Monarch Notes 1963). Therefore, sense knowledge alone can not be counted upon to fulfill all the requirements needed to prove the truth to a specific state of being, object, or even a persons existence.

If this was totally relied upon, one would never fully know when they were awake or asleep because the senses can fool you. The senses form a type of illusion over the mind in a dreaming state, so in this regard a persons rationalization would be clouded and not wholly fact based. Because it is understood that sense impression is independent of free will, a dream state can not be for certain, nor can a wakeful state (Monarch Notes 1963). However, since human beings are rational thinkers, and we can rationalize the idea of wakefulness, humans thus have the ability to be able to discuss the feelings of being awake and interpret the concept.

Nevertheless, in a state of sleep, human beings are not aware when they go to sleep and because of that can not logically state when they are asleep, even though they might be (Kumar 2001). For example, the experience of a dream within a dream has taken place with more than one person. In this type of state you feel your awake when you really are still asleep. So, the senses can be very tricky and inaccurate when trying to solve certain questions about life, spirituality, and objects. It appears that Descartes is right in his belief that there truly is no accurate way to state for sure when an individual is really asleep, and when they actually move into wakefulness.

Not if a person is looking for definitive proof, anyway. The same is true for dreaming. Though people do dream (as this has been researched), individually a person can not know that they are dreaming because they can't even prove they are asleep. Dreaming and sleeping or not conscious thoughts, and therein lies the reasoning why they can not be proven when they

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Descartes and Dreaming Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1527006-descartes-and-dreaming
(Descartes and Dreaming Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1527006-descartes-and-dreaming.
“Descartes and Dreaming Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1527006-descartes-and-dreaming.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Descartes and Dreaming

How to Know One Exists

If I convinced myself of something [or thought anything at all], than I certainly existed” (descartes, 1984: 16).... The main point that descartes shows is based first on the assumption that the physical does not truly exist.... This particular concept is further pointed out by descartes with the belief that one is only able to exist because this is what they perceive....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Meditations on First Philosophy by Ren Descartes

However, this reasoning is easily challenged under the theory of doubt; he says that although he uses the fire to determine he is awake, even when he is dreaming, he experiences similar sensations to the ones he is currently feeling.... Date Rene descartes is widely considered the father of modern philosophy; this assumption is not in justified considering he broke away from the traditional philosophies more so the Scholastic Aristotelian ones that were widely accepted....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Descartes First Meditation paper and Moore's Certainty paper

Provocatively, Moore challenges the argument concerning ones inability to know whether he is dreaming.... In the logical inversion of Descartes argument, Moore argues that, if one knows not that he is dreaming, one knows not that he standing.... Additionally, one can be dreaming or think he is standing and in actual sense, he is standing.... This is the only case where dreaming and thinking to standing and standing at the same time is consistent....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Life of Rene Descartes

Your Name Due Date Rene descartes: Life and Times Joachim descartes, and, his wife, Jeanne Brochard, welcomed their son, Rene, on March 31, 1596.... The descartes family was quite wealthy; the majority of the relatives were in the fields of medicine or law.... However it was mathematics that most attracted the young descartes.... Although is believed to have received his degree from University of Poiters in civil and canon law between 1615 and 1616, there is a period on and off throughout 1614-1618, where descartes fell out of the world, many believe that he may have some sort of emotional or mental break-down and was in seclusion n Paris, France (Skirry )....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Dependability of Science Based on Empiricism

The focus of the paper "Modern Philosophy" is on descartes's argument, mind and body to bond, descartes Cartesian dualism, assumption, instructor Date From antiquity to contemporary times, Rene descartes, a critical factor that emerges, from antiquity to contemporary times.... Essentially, descartes was seen as deigning to question the dependability of science-based on empiricism since scientific investigation can only be an inference by means of sensory examination....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Dream Argument as a Postulation by Descartes

He argues that the act of dreaming is a preliminary evidence of the possibility that the senses that people rely on to make a distinction between reality and illusions are not trustworthy.... The people, while in the dream, do not have the knowledge that they are dreaming, they only come to realize they were dreaming when they wake.... Thus, this then raises the basis of the dream argument as Descartes presents it, that, there is the possibility that people are constantly dreaming and never wake into reality....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Explain Descartes skeptical argument according to a prompt

The dream argument can thus be presented as (Descartes 33): The crucial step Descartes make in his dream doubt This lack of insight forms the basis of the argument as the mediator notices that there are certain instances when he is convinced he is awake and surrounded by real objects but he is in fact sleeping and dreaming.... First is that dreams have an inexhaustible ability to mimic the real world and secondly, whether dreaming or awake, the clearest thoughts of intellect remain uncompromised....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper

Explain Descartes skeptical argument according to a prompt

The process of having dreams is referred to as dreaming.... Research has shown that sleepwalkers are indeed dreaming.... descartes says that there are no conclusive signs that show the distinction between being awake or asleep.... In the first meditation, descartes states that we cannot have knowledge of the external world and our bodies based on the senses....
4 Pages (1000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us