StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Vicarious Liability -Legal Aspects in Health Care - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essence of this paper is to explain the medical concept, vicarious liability; its definition and case, particularly one based on medical negligence in a hospital or health care organization. Vicarious liability extends its arm to Hospitals and health care organizations where…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.1% of users find it useful
Vicarious Liability -Legal Aspects in Health Care
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Vicarious Liability -Legal Aspects in Health Care"

Running Head: Vicarious Liability – Legal Aspects in Health Care The essence of this paper is to explain the medical concept, vicarious liability; its definition and case, particularly one based on medical negligence in a hospital or health care organization. Vicarious liability extends its arm to Hospitals and health care organizations where in most cases, medical malpractices due to negligence or deliberately by unqualified medical personnel’s undoing are witnessed. Introduction In most cases, a person(s), organizations, companies, hospitals or health care providing institutions are held accountable for their employee’s wrongdoings.

In legal terms, this act is referred to as vicarious liability. It allows for holding an employer responsible for the persons working under their instructions irrespective of whether they are employees or independent contractors, whether they committed the crime intentionally, unintentionally, neglectfully or with criminal oriented intentions. In common knowledge, the boss or an employer, who in other words is the employing authority, should take liability. This is because ideally, the employer has the fattest bank accounts compared to their employees, has the ability to access insurance indemnity and by virtue of the authority bestowed upon it, it can encourage its personnel to use the medical etiquette and ethics professionally.

Just as a parent is liable for his/her child’s mistake, the medical care organization should take vicarious liability (Devine, 2009) Lawmedconsultant.com observes that Ellis Memorial hospital, located in Tarpon Springs, Florida was served with two medical lawsuits of professional negligence. Shirley Reth brought two-consolidated lawsuits on behalf of the estate of Reth. The suits concerned Sean Reth who had undergone an unsuccessful aesthetical surgery at the hospital in March 2006 but died three days later due to Anesthesia Medical personnel’s malpractices, as Reth argued in the summons.

This led to insufficient supply of oxygenated blood to the patients’ brain, medically referred as cerebral ischemia, along with intra-operative cardiac arrest, in other words, heart attack. In this case, Anesthetic associates of North Pinellas PA, PA, Teresa catsos CRNA, Hugh Siegel, CRNA together with Glen Syperda, D.O. an Anesthesiologist and the hospital were the defendants. Even if the defendants were not directly employed by the hospital, it was the hospital’s responsibility to take the initiative and bear the brunt of the personnel that was working under its instructions.

According to Reth the barrister, Mr. Reth’s death resulted from neglectful anesthesia care. He claimed that providing non-negligent anesthesia care to patients is the hospital’s non-delegable responsibility in spite of who in essence provides that care in their operating room. Consequently, the hospital was vicariously accountable for the performed anesthesia services. Reth conceded that pursuant to a contract with the Hospital, Anesthesia Associates hired nurse anesthetists and physicians to provide anesthesia services.

Reth claimed that in providing anesthesia services to the patient during the surgery, the certified registered nurse anesthetists as well as the anesthesiologist were neglectful, which culminated into his death. He cited Florida Administrative Code Rule 59A-3.2085(4), Florida Statutes (2005), sections 395.002(13)(b) and 395.1055(1)(a), (d), which created an express legal obligation for the Hospital to provide its surgical patients with non-negligent anesthesia services. The jury later on turned down some of the facts that Reth as an advocate pointed out because he could not establish and sustain supportive and credible evidence to back his claims.

For instance, since a qualified medical practitioner supervised the entire operation, he must have certified it with the doctor’s academic qualifications and he must have ensured the positive outcome and error free exercise (Lawmedconsultant.com, 2010). ConclusionVicarious liability is a commonplace terminology in the legal world. Having known what it is and its essence, it is important to conclude that it is good news to those employees or contracted parties that are innocent and it is high time the courts realized that to determine cases of this nature in view of what plight that may befall the employee.

After verdicts, employers as well learn on what to do in the future in the event of similar anomalies and become cautious to guard and manage situations forehand. In this respect, the employers learn to avoid risks especially from those who are susceptible to risk.ReferencesDevine, J. (2009): What is Vicarious Liability? Retrieved August 11, 2010 from http://ezinearticles.com/?What-is-Vicarious-Liability?&id=1932348Lawmedconsultant.com, (2010): Vicarious Liability in Anesthesia Malpractice: Florida Experience.

Retrieved August 11, 2010 from http://lawmedconsultant.com/750/vicarious-liability-in-anesthesia-malpractice-florida-experience

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Vicarious Liability -Legal Aspects in Health Care Essay - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1569100-vicarious-liability-legal-aspects-in-health-care
(Vicarious Liability -Legal Aspects in Health Care Essay - 1)
https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1569100-vicarious-liability-legal-aspects-in-health-care.
“Vicarious Liability -Legal Aspects in Health Care Essay - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1569100-vicarious-liability-legal-aspects-in-health-care.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Vicarious Liability -Legal Aspects in Health Care

Health Care Practice: the Managers Role in the Running of a Health Care Practice

health care practice Name Institution health care practice The General Practice managers are individuals within a health care practice that oversee and develop the functions of a general practice surgeon or a group of surgeons.... For example, in Newham borough the demand for primary health care is huge.... For example, in Newham in the Tower hamlets borough, the major service is primary health care.... In this case, the competition comes from the National health Service....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

NHS Redress Scheme

The introduction of the Bill for NHS Redress Scheme to provide a consistent, speedy and appropriate response when something goes wrong with a patient's hospital care, and to provide investigations, explanations, apologies and financial compensation where appropriate has been a welcome step in the UK healthcare system.... By terms of the NHS Redress Bill, patients will no longer have to go to court to get compensation, care, apologies and investigations if something goes wrong with their NHS hospital treatment or care....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Health care-long term and capstone discussions 2

Select one type of long-term care and present 3 barriers to successful cultural change in your selected type of long-term care.... Being a transformational tool, culture change depicts a movement in itself that tries to establish… In long-term care, culture change is a vital aspect for residents' rights.... Community based services are a long term care type which somebody may draw interest and talk about.... They include; personal care, adult day care, and transportation services among others....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Alzheimers Disease in Australia

The steps include taking care of the heart, physical activity, brain activity, healthy diet and social activity to further stabilize the health of the brain (Australian Indigenous Health, 2013).... It must be mentioned that the kit has been made with regard to biological, psychological and behavioral symptom associated with the health… Notably, the social aspect of dementia was also taken into consideration for better diagnosis of the diseases amid the clients with the help of the resource kit....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Health Care Law and Ethics

health care is a profession that requires great care and attention as required by the health care ethics.... However, the health care professionals are governed by the health care law that governs their work and also their duties.... … health care is one of the professions that require one to be careful and have compassion to the patients as he or she deals with many people from different backgrounds and races....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Medico-legal Issues in Radiology Case Analaysing

For instance, prescribing a medicine incompatible with the disease that could result in allergies or severe side effects (Heath 1998, 34) A legal principle called the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur, meaning “the thing speaks for itself' permits bypassing of the procedure of going through these four aspects.... "Medico-legal Issues in Radiology Case Analyzing" paper discusses the case, in terms of negligence, focuses on the roles of both Leo and Polly....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Vicarious Liability

This paper ''vicarious liability'' tells that this form of liability is a joint liability in both persons; one who committed the tort and the employer can be sued.... hellip; In modern jurisdictions, vicarious liability cases have been reported in relationships involving employers and their employees, where the subject of the relationship is always work-related.... Among many other factors that make vicarious liability legally and ethically justified will include the proof of the following three main elements....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Health and Social Care: Interactions with Older People

… The paper "Health and Social care: Interactions with Older People" is a wonderful example of an assignment on social science.... As a student, this course study has taught me a lot when it comes to taking care of these groups of people.... The paper "Health and Social care: Interactions with Older People" is a wonderful example of an assignment on social science.... As a student, this course study has taught me a lot when it comes to taking care of these groups of people....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us