StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Sociology Ethics in Nursing - Report Example

Summary
This report "Sociology Ethics in Nursing" discusses whether or not the life of a terminally ill patient should be preserved is debatable in the field of nursing. Medical practitioners may not be willing to end the life of a patient who seems to show the potential to heal…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "Sociology Ethics in Nursing"

Applying Law and Ethics in Practice Introduction The principles of ethics and law are applicable in various fields including nursing and they are crucial especially when making medically related decisions concerning the life of a patient as presented in the case of James B. In that regard, the case presents a quadriplegic patient who is forced to be fed via a PEG catheter in his stomach, something most patients do not enjoy. The patient has a reached a point where he demands the discontinuation of nutrition from the PEG claiming that his life is intolerable and that he wants to be allowed to die. Additionally, the patient has the ability to communicate and is considered mentally competent and also has good psychological support from family members. Hence, this raises ethical issues on the part of nurses and the medical practitioners on whether or not he should be given access to the right to die. The code of ethics for nurses provides guidance for ethical responsibilities, decision-making, behaviors and relationships in cases such as these. The code is also a means for self-reflection and self-evaluation for ethical nursing. It is also an ethical basis whereby nurses are put in a position to advocate for good work environments that lead to the provision of safe, competent, compassionate and ethical care. Therefore, this essay will identify the key issues raised in this scenario using the ethical principles of autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice. The Principle of Autonomy Autonomy can be defined as self-determination and self-governance and when nurses seek to protect the dignity of the patients they care for, then they show respect for autonomy (Bird, 2009). This allows patients to make decisions concerning their choice of treatment. In addition to that, the practice of informed consent that needs to be respected by the nurse is grounded. A patient is allowed to write a directive in advance in the event of being incapacitated to make informed choices hence enabling the patient to maintain autonomy. According to the code of ethics for nurses, the principle of autonomy expects medical practitioners to respect the decision of a patient, having the capacity to make decisions to forgo treatment that is life-sustaining (Beauchamp, 2001). By definition, life-sustaining treatment is treatment that intends to prolong life without necessarily reversing the current medical condition (Burcher, 2004). In this case, James is undergoing life-sustaining treatment by artificial nutrition and hydration. He is also said to be mentally competent and thus has been able to make the informed decision about ending his life by withdrawal of food. In such a case, nurses know that food is essential for the life of James and as healthcare professionals; they may be reluctant to deny their patient food. In addition to that, the kind of feeding he receives intends to act as medical therapy. It is an invasive method of feeding that needs nutritional expertise and skilled nursing since it is associated with complications. Furthermore, the supportive family members of James would not want him to die of hunger. However, in spite of all these uncertainties, James has qualified by law to the principle of autonomy since he is of sound mind. The next step therefore lies with the doctors. Many of such cases are normally presented in the court of law especially when the doctor becomes unwilling to give the patient his or her right to autonomy. Included in the right to autonomy, is the right of every human being that is an adult and of sound mind to make a decision about his or her own body (Bernheim, 2003). This principle thus implies that a service provider or medical practitioner such as a nurse who provides treatment that goes against the wishes of a patient who is mentally competent breaks the law since he trespasses against the individual. Hence, according to the law, James has the right to decide whether or not he wants to continue to be treated. Nurses promote and respect the autonomy of persons and assist them to be in a position to express their health values and needs and to get the desired services and information so that they are able to make informed decisions (Bird, 2004). Principle of Beneficence Beneficence is acting in a way that will benefit others; it incorporates balancing of benefits over harm and also requires nurses to take action (Kass, 2001). This principle may result in ethical issues especially when there is some form of conflict concerning what is good between the organizations and patients, between the nurse and patient, between patients and between states. There is a general agreement that the good of the patient should come before the good of the organization or the good of the nurse but nurses confuse what the patient’s good is with what the nurse’s belief in what seems good for the patient is. Thus, there is an underlying debate concerning what should be good for a patient without necessarily violating the autonomy of the patient or letting the patient inflict or cause harm to him or herself. Hence, the question is whether or not it is right for nurses to overrule the preferences of their patients. In the case of James, the nurses may see that it is not right to end his life through the method of withdrawing food since it will result in starvation and eventually undesirable death. In that connection, they may prefer an alternative method that seems good to the patient thereby foregoing his decision to withdraw food. In this case, this is beneficence since the nurse feels that it is for the good of the patient if he does not die by starvation but rather another method that seems effective and tolerable to James. In addition to that, the nurses may find that James is making the decision under the influence of stressful circumstances such as the desire to end an intolerable life. Weak paternalism involves the protection of the patient by the nurse in the case where the patient is not in a position to make informed decisions due to challenges of depression or medical influence. On the contrary, strong paternalism intends to benefit a patient even though the risky actions and choices of the patient are voluntary, informed and autonomous. Thus, the nurses may decide to practice strong paternalism it benefits to James. Principle of non-maleficence This principle gives nurses the duty of ensuring that they refrain from causing harm on the patient. In the case of James, non-maleficence may be as a result of complications caused by the mode of feeding, in this case the PEG catheter in his stomach. This makes him not to enjoy his food and thus may result in prolonged suffering. The nurses may thus have the need to restrain the patient from the experience that seems to cause harm by withdrawing the PEG catheter thus complying to his wish to die. In addition to that, non-maleficence can be caused by communication failure between the nurse and the patient where the nurse decides to overlook the needs of the patient with the belief that the patient is not in a bad state. Moreover, the withdrawal of the PEG may also result in harm on the body of the patient. In addition, it is stated that James communicates via a tracheotomy and by the movement of his two fingers. This form of communication may be interpreted in different ways by different nurses thus resulting in a failure to give accurate information about the patient. Moreover, the breaking down of the equipment that is used to feed him may also result in the cause of harm to the patient. The harm that is caused may be life-threatening and result in heart attacks or strokes. Principle of Justice Justice is aligned with what a patient deserves. It can be determined in terms of equality, fairness, need or other justice decisions. In the field of nursing, justice refers to equitable access to care where resources are scarcely allocated. In that regard, elderly patients also have the right to access treatment regardless of their age. Percutaneous gastronomy (PEG) catheter has been inserted in the stomach of James so that the burden of nursing is reduced even though it was not the interest of the patient. The use of this mode of feeding should be considered in terms of cost effectiveness or whether there are other options for James. In addition to that, the decision of James to stop the feeding by the PEG catheter and the kind of treatment he receives in the nursing home needs to be determined by finding out how it affects the availability of treatment on others. Nurses also have the obligation to provide competent, ethical and safe care to all their patients. The denial of these will be denying justice to the patient. Nurses also have the obligation to preserve the sanctity of life. An exception to preserving the sanctity of the patient is when he or she is suffering from terminal illness and untreatable conditions that make the patient go through immense suffering (Mann, 1999). In the event of preserving the sanctity of the life of James, the nurses and medical practitioners provided him with nutrition and hydration until it reached a point whereby he turned the treatment down. The provision of food to James before he refused the feeding meant to give him quality life even as he was in hospital. The law forbids nurses and physicians to give treatment to against a patient’s will and if the nurses do so without considering the decisions by the patient, they may face ethical, professional and legal censure. Conclusion The decision of whether or not the life of a terminally ill patient should be preserved is debatable in the field of nursing. Medical practitioners may not be willing to end the life of a patient who seems to show the potential to heal while the patient may want to die due to the intolerable prevailing circumstances. It even becomes difficult when the decision is to die is made by a patient who is fully aware of the present situation. It has been shown that nurses have an obligation to practice the principles of ethics during the practice of their profession. The principle of autonomy is exclusive to the patient as long as he or she is of sound mind and is thus capable of making informed decisions. The principle of beneficence involves doing what is good to the patient and it is this principle that has caused debate in the field of nursing. The principle of justice states that all patients should receive the limited resources of health care while the principle of non-maleficence gives nurses the duty not to cause harm on their patients. Thus, these principles were clearly demonstrated in the case of James and it shows how important the ethical principles for nursing are in aiding patients to make informed decisions. List of References Beauchamp, T. 2001. Principles of Biomedical Ethics. Oxford: Oxford University Press Bernheim, R. 2003. Public Health Ethics: The Voices of Practitioners. The Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics, 31 (4), 104-109. Bird, S. 2009. To Treat or Not to Treat. Australian Family Physician, 38 (11), pp. 23-40. Burcher, B. 2004. Ethics and Community Health Nursing in Canada. St. Louis, MO: Mosby Kass, N. 2001. An Ethics Framework for Public Health. American Journal of Public Health, 91 (11), 1776-1782. Mann, T. 1999. Health and Human Rights: A Reader. New York: Routledge. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Sociology Ethics in Nursing

Nursing pre-requisites

Pre-requisites for a BSN Nursing Program Bachelor of Science in nursing (BSN) is a professional nursing program that develops an individual's nursing career on the foundation of knowledge in humanities, science, and other associated professional disciplines.... In addition, a greater level of expertise in nursing science is also required to cope with the fast changing health care situations and to promote patient safety.... Increasing health care complexities necessitates nursing candidates to be more competitive by gaining deep knowledge in various areas of science....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Social Work Nursing Case Study

A nurse working tend to have interactions with the children nursing is a profession which really teaches you beside other professional knowledge as to how to become more patient and serve the humanity with all your heart and soul.... Further nursing as a profession has evolved over the period of time and has now emerged one of the highly respectable and demanding professions of the world.... With these aims in my mind, I chose to consider nursing as my professionNursing, as a profession, need to have a balanced view where the new entrants into the profession must also know about the academic knowledge of their profession however, they must possess the knowledge of the practical realities of the profession also....
6 Pages (1500 words) Case Study

Ethical Dilemma in Nursing

The study "Ethical Dilemma in nursing" focuses on the critical analysis of the ethical dilemma revolving around a gentleman Mr.... However, the nursing intervention could be seen as a contradiction of his rights yet would enable him to stay alive (Rumbold 1993).... A carefully performed study of the outcomes of nursing home patients with advanced dementia and eating disorders found that the patients who were fed through a gastrostomy tube and those who continued to be fed by hand had the same survival rates (Rethinking....
14 Pages (3500 words) Case Study

Evaluation of Sociological Methods

The essay "Evaluation of Sociological Methods" describes and discusses the main methods of sociology discipline.... sociology is simply the study of society.... sociology itself is a relatively new academic discipline and came into acceptance as science only in the early part of the nineteenth century.... Many fundamental discoveries in sociology have been made, reviewed, established, evaluated, and adjusted according to new data in the past decades....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Sociology of Nursing and Patient Care

The sociology of nursing requires that nurses pay close attention to their patients needs so that they feel comfortable and relaxed.... The essay "The Sociology of nursing and Patient Care" follows an observational approach to analyze abilities of a nurse's routine with this particular patient, using literary materials and a reflective type of perspective.... One of the main negativities that are found in this girl's circumstance is in how the nursing staffs relative indifference towards this patient makes her feel alienated, which could also pose as a complication from a cultural perspective since the racial identity is left to be questioned....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Critical Analysis of the Research Designs in a Peer- Reviewed Article

This editorial provides an overview of qualitative research, describes 3 common types of qualitative research, and gives examples of their use in nursing” (par.... Part 2: qualitative designs” written by Jenny Ploeg (1999) exemplifies research using the qualitative method identified to be crucial in providing answers to relevant nursing concerns.... The article was chosen to be the appropriate example of a peer-reviewed discourse which explains a research design, specifically the qualitative method, as a means of furthering trends on nursing applications, a significant area of health science....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Nursing theory reviewed

The health perspective in nursing tends to define health as a condition in which all body parts are in harmony with the client, here the client being the patient.... Personal knowledge of nursing, conceptual knowledge of the field and dimensional understanding of aesthetics of the empirical knowledge in nursing field influence the community to further their studies on the applications to health care.... Integrated theory and knowledge development in nursing (7th ed....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Professionalism in Health and Human Service Delivery

rofessionalism in nursing care is an important term that has dominated the discussion with regard to what is expected of the nursing care professional.... hile professionalism in nursing care has been defined in the context of autonomy in actual practice professional nursing is not autonomous.... The paper 'Professionalism in Health and Human Service Delivery' is a pathetic example of an essay on nursing.... The nursing profession has experienced exponential growth since its introduction as a critical component of health care....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us