StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Failure of Solids: Markham Colliery Disaster - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
This essay explores the investigation of the cause of the Markham colliery accident. The proper system design should be emphasized while making such a system in the mine as this would have saved lives and such other fatalities as resulted from the crash…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96% of users find it useful
Failure of Solids: Markham Colliery Disaster
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Failure of Solids: Markham Colliery Disaster"

Executive summary Eighteen men fell culprits and died in the 1973 Markham colliery disaster in which other eleven persons sustained serious injuries after a cage descending into the mine failed to stop while reaching the base of the mineshaft. Moreover, another person was reported to have sustained very bad injuries suffered during the rescue process. A fracture in the brake rod of the crane is what the report that was released after an investigation into the accident indicated to have been the cause to the crash. The braking system as was relied upon to slow down the cage as it descended people into the mine failed because of metal fatigue as was later discovered. The braking system as was used in the operation of the cage comprised of mechanical braking system as well as regenerative braking system using direct current kind of power as was used in powering the double deck descending cages. A system of levers as well as braking pads were relied upon in the mechanical braking process, besides, some steel rods were in use for transmitting braking pressure from the spring nests towards the main levers and as such, the steel rods would always be under tension whenever brakes were applied in the system. However, the system mechanical functionality has a standby system of braking which is applied in the event of an emergency. This is what the ‘winding engine man’ on duty (Kennan) claims to have failed simultaneously with the internal braking system, and hence resulted in the crash-landing of the cage. The investigation that ensued to determine the exact cause of the accident found nothing more to be associated with the accident except the fatigue and resultant breaking of the braking rod as was relied upon to produce the braking effect of the winding system. In fact the analysis showed that the materials used in manufacture of those breaking rod was the perfect type from industrial specifications and hence fatigue was blamed on causing the breakage and hence the failure. Report Outline of the accident: On the 6th of March in 1974, the ‘secretary of state for energy’, Varley Eric Graham tabled the findings of the investigations into the cause of the accident as was investigated with the direction by Peter Walker (the secretary of state for trade and industry)at the time after the accident. The report confirmed that eighteen persons lost their lives in the accident with at least twelve other persons sustaining serious injuries through the accident and during the rescue mission. The report was compiled from a public inquiry that was commenced immediately after the accident and fifty-five persons gave evidence of the account as to what transpired. The report established that the fatalities were caused by a crash into the bottom of the mine that happened after the cage in which the men were travelling in failed to brake upon nearing the base of the mine. Besides, there ensued a delay in reaching for the injured after the mine gates suffered distortion and they were rescued hours after the accident happened. Through the evidence presented by the public inquiry, the much sought after information in understanding the intrigues that would have caused the over-wind with the system of the cage was gotten. After the analysis, the accident was found to have resulted after the cage system that ferried miners into the mine failed to brake hence crash landing into the bottom of the mine. The failure resulted from material fatigue that affected the steel metal rods, which supported the breaking mechanism for the cages as they descended into the mine. Evidence: The investigation led to a number of revelations, which included that, all system of brakes; even the emergency braking system failed. The mechanical system functionality has a standby braking system, which is applied for emergencies. However, according to the ‘winding engine man’ on duty the system failed simultaneously with the system’s main braking system, and hence resulted to the crash-landing of the cage. According to Kennan, sparks were observed below the braking cylinder and he immediately ensued retarding the winding. The immediate action was to apply the regenerative system of brakes together with pulling to position the brake lever. After noting no effect from the systems of brake, he applied the emergency stopping system, which equally failed to the utter dismay of him, and this therefore caused the cage to crash to the ground hence causing the fatalities as were. Working practices and system design: the cage system comprises of the system through which a winding motor is powered through direct current motor. The winding rope has two cages wound at each end and which serves as the containers in which the people are transported through, to and from the mine. The operation of the system had the mechanical braking system released and gradual application of the DC power to the motor. After an initial acceleration, the system acquires and maintains a constant speed of 6m/s until the cages approach the bottom after which deceleration commences through reduction in power voltage supply. Deceleration is followed by a mechanical braking system, which is responsible of complete halting of the cages at the bottom. An 8 feet long steel rod was strategically placed between the ‘spring nests’ and the ‘main lever’ and had the main role of transmitting the force. The compression of then springs therefore yield pressure on the rod always and this explains the continued tension that the rod suffers. Besides, safety is ensured through automatic system of supply of power, which would disconnect the motor from the main power source whenever applied and automatically applies the mechanical braking system. This therefore shows that the working of the cage system in the mine is well designed and its effectiveness assured if not for such total system failure as was blamed for having caused the accident. At the time of accident, the cage had fifteen men on board with fourteen others in the lower compartment and after being loaded at the surface, the descent was normal until past the midway when Kennan noticed sparks and his efforts to retard the engine became fruitless. After applying all emergency control measures, Kennan notes that noting happened until the cages crash-landed at the bottom of the mine hence resulting to the deaths and the injuries. During the examination, metallurgical test on the steel rods revealed the breaking resulted from strain and fatigue. However, after crack detection through electromagnetic methods, only minor defects got detected but greasing and lubrication was shown to have lacked although these defects would not explain the accident. Conclusion and recommendations The report presented after the investigation of the cause of the Markham colliery accident was instrumental in establishing that total mechanical failure in the system caused it. However, the main weakness was found with the centre rod, which suffered fatigue and strain and hence broke thereby disabling all other systems in operation; even the emergency ones. Design problem was established in that the system did not consider spring nest high pressures and there had been no efforts to lubricate all the axles. This therefore explains the recommendations of this paper that proper system design should be emphasized while making such a system in the mine as this would have saved lives and such other fatalities as resulted from the crash. Proper lubrication and frequent stress analysis for the supportive rods is necessary in such a system and this would aid in early detection of possible breakages due to stress and fatigue and hence have timely repair and maintenance procedures. Finally, slow emergency response mechanism would equally be pointed out as to have been a feature in the rescue operation and this paper therefore recommends that a regulatory body should be constituted to oversee such prompt response to emergencies is ensured. Bibliography Calder J. W. 1974. “Accident at Markham Colliery Derbyshire: Report” Viewed April 2, 2014, Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Failure of Solids: Markham Colliery Disaster Case Study”, n.d.)
Failure of Solids: Markham Colliery Disaster Case Study. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/engineering-and-construction/1818379-failure-of-solids-case-study-about-the-markham-colliery-disaster
(Failure of Solids: Markham Colliery Disaster Case Study)
Failure of Solids: Markham Colliery Disaster Case Study. https://studentshare.org/engineering-and-construction/1818379-failure-of-solids-case-study-about-the-markham-colliery-disaster.
“Failure of Solids: Markham Colliery Disaster Case Study”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/engineering-and-construction/1818379-failure-of-solids-case-study-about-the-markham-colliery-disaster.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Failure of Solids: Markham Colliery Disaster

Importance of the Stress Test

Full Paper Title Name University disaster Recovery Plan In order to minimize the likelihood of the system, there must be a stress test for all the core components on the network on monthly or weekly basis, depending on the size of the network.... In case of a natural disaster, data must be relocated on a separate data center situated far away geographically.... disaster Recovery Plan The disaster recovery plan covering all the issues and counter measures is demonstrated below (Sandhu, 2002): Threats Counter Measures Power Failure Alternate power distribution link Database Failure Backing up data on 3 different locations at the same time by disk mirroring, ciphering, DLT or manual backup on daily basis....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Workplace Communication

The article has also a subliminal message that even the smartest people such as those in NASA are also having issues on how to… Above all, the article stressed how critical it is to communicate clearly for the intended message to effectively reach to the intended party. In the case of the Challenger disaster, the engineers already knew that the O-rings used on the solid rocket I.... n the case of the Challenger disaster, the engineers already knew that the O-rings used on the solid rocket boosters had shown a potential for failure....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Alternative explaination for any one of the follow technological failures

It will be seen that instead of providing an alternative explanation, Perrow's theory basically enhances one's understanding of the technological failure of Swissair 111, explaining the reason for the crash to take place, as an inevitable or ‘normal' accident.... Thus, how Charles Perrow's theory of normal accidents explaining the Three Mile Island disaster can be used to explain the Swissair 111 accident which took place on the 2nd of September, 1998 will be examined....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Hadron collider

It has been labeled as the biggest, most costly and powerful device ever created.... All other element colliders previously built have… The LHC is a collider that was recently finished in Switzerland Geneva, as a project by the organization CERN (Campanelli, Clark and Wu 141). Researchers from CERN built the device in anticipation of gaining knowledge concerning Hadron collider and its dangers The Large Hadron collider (LHC) is an atom accelerator situated at the France/Switzerlandboundary (Datta, Mukhopadhyaya and Raychaudhuri 160)....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Density of regular solids

The experiment was carried out in two phases: the first phase involved determining the density of fluids, and the second determining the density of aluminium using two methods; direct determination and displacement method. This involved taking measurements such as the radius,… The measurements were taken four times and density calculated for every set of values....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Solids Conveying

The operation of the two conveyors depends on one gear, however the conveyors move in opposite direction.... The use of a single gear is to ensure that… The system involves the movement of products or commodities from one floor to another.... For example, in assembly factories or industries, they move parts or products from one floor to another, thus enhance efficiency in In our everyday life, items need to move from one point to another, for efficiency, for different reasons such as construction, packaging in industries, assembly houses and manufacturing industries....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Management of Disasters

The decentralization of disaster response enhances effectiveness and efficiency.... hellip; Due to the severity in the need of ensuring that the occurrence of disasters does not outwit efforts that can be made by government through state institutions in responding effectively to the disasters, there has often been the call for collaboration with other agencies in disaster management in control.... Due to the severity in the need of ensuring that the occurrence of disasters do not outwit efforts that can be made by government through state institutions in responding effectively to the disasters, there have often being the call for collaboration with other agencies in disaster management in control....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

The BP Explosion and Vioxx Disaster

In the paper “The BP Explosion and Vioxx disaster” the author describes the most detrimental tragedies, globally.... hellip; The author states that the same factors that facilitated the Vioxx disaster are evident in the BP explosion.... The Vioxx disaster occurred between 1999 and 2004.... Flirting with disaster: Why Accidents Are Rarely Accidental.... Flirting with disaster: Why Accidents are rarely Accidental' recounts the event and experiences of the BP Texas refinery explosion and Vioxx disaster....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us